By Sheldon J. Stark – Mediator and Arbitrator
Because no two disputes are precisely alike, the best tools for settling them are probably not the same, either. Fortunately, mediation is a flexible process, which can be tailored to meet the unique aspects of each matter; and the individual and specific needs and interests of the parties and litigators involved. To get the most out of the mediation process, therefore, every dispute warrants careful analysis and evaluation to determine which style or method of mediation would be best.
As many litigators are either unfamiliar with joint sessions or reluctant to incorporate joint sessions into their practice, this paper will provide some background and recommendations for why you should consider giving joint sessions a try.
What are joint sessions?
Joint sessions come in many different formats. The most common is where parties and counsel remain in the same room following delivery of the mediator’s opening statement. In this model, the participants – lawyers, parties or lawyers and par ties – take advantage of the opportunity to speak directly to one another by making preliminary remarks or opening statements. Sometimes only the lawyers speak; sometimes only the parties; but often both. Plaintiff might explain why he brought the suit. Defendant might share her perspective and why she agreed to mediate.
Counsel might share their view of the legal framework. Each side is expected to listen to the other without interruption. After opening remarks, the par ties may remain together to answer questions from the mediator – or each other – if everyone agrees.
A joint session may be used to exchange information, share personal perspective or identify potential risk directly, rather than as translated or presented by the mediator. A joint session may also be used to deliver an effective apology or acknowledgement concerning personal responsibility; to deliver a complicated offer or counter-offer coupled with an explanation; or, to engage in confidence building discussions to begin repair of a prior constructive relationship.
In another joint session model, the parties may not be interested in making formal opening presentations. However, they may be willing to remain together in a joint session after the mediator’s opening remarks to answer simple factual questions, identify key topics to discuss, seek agreements regarding the law, find common ground, trim the number of issues to discuss or consider process changes since the
pre-mediation conference call. An additional party, for example, may be attending who was not previously expected.
In still another model, the parties remain in caucus mode until the mediator suggests a joint session has become appropriate. The mediator might wish to bring everyone together to discuss certain clearly identified issues: are the parties interested in relationship repair? Do they both agree that a certain event took place? Is there agreement surrounding the legal issues? Do the parties agree about the orientation of the judge deciding a dispositive motion? If they’ve done business together in the past, would it be useful to discuss doing so again in the future? In an employment case where the plaintiff remains employed, a joint session to discuss how the parties will work together may help avoid future conflicts. Perhaps new channels of communication are needed. A joint session provides a golden opportunity to craft them.
If key decision makers are present at the table from each side, putting the CEOs together to hammer out final details is often a productive use of the joint session after relying on joint sessions to bring the parties close to resolution.
When parties keep an open mind concerning process and timing, other creative uses of the joint session can be identified to increase the likelihood of reaching agreement. Despite the advantages and benefits of joint sessions, the caucus model with “shuttle diplomacy” is the preferred approach for most Michigan litigators. This paper will explore some of the reasons why and highlight the value of joint sessions. My hope is that litigators and their clients will give joint sessions due consideration before making final decisions about process design.
The Michigan climate for joint sessions
Most Michigan litigators today opt for an “all caucus all the time” model of mediation with the mediator engaged in shuttle diplomacy like Henry Kissinger or Jimmy Carter. All across the state disputants ignore or fail to consider joint sessions in their process design. Only occasionally are they willing to consider the possibility of a joint session.
Why? Sometimes the litigators have good reasons:
• The parties or lawyers are already aggravated and upset with one another. Putting them together in the same room will only make matters worse and undermine the negotiation process.
• Counsel fear their clients will blurt out something damaging
or harmful to the process.
• The parties have been through discovery and believe
they will learn nothing new. Accordingly, a joint session is seen as a waste of time and resources.
• There is little or no trust coupled with a belief they will hear
nothing honest.
• One or both sides have concluded the other won’t listen, so why bother?
• A participant is reluctant to share information in joint session because discovery isn’t over or they’re “saving it for trial.” 2
• Attorneys fear their clients won’t live up to direction from counsel to conceal their emotions and limit their remarks.
Some mediators suspect there are additional reasons:
• Inexperience: Lawyers who have not seen an effectively managed joint session find it difficult to appreciate the many advantages joint sessions offer.
• Inertia: Lawyers have always defaulted to an all caucus model and see no reason to change.
• Ignorance: Many lawyers are unaware that they can participate in process design to tailor the individual mediation process to the dispute.
• Time: Preparing for a joint session can require additional time and preparation. Sometimes busy practitioners lack the time and resources to adequately prepare.
• Preparation anxiety: Busy litigators fear they may have overlooked something and do not want to appear unprepared without an adequate explanation in front of the other side – or their client.
• Competitive instincts: Some litigators are concerned their clients will inadvertently give something away or provide the other side with an advantage they did not anticipate.
• Manipulation: Some lawyers hope to use the mediator to do or say things they wouldn’t do or say themselves.
• Control: Advocates can maximize their control over the process and negotiation by shaping each message the mediator carries into the other room.
• Lack of encouragement: Some mediators have little or no experience with joint sessions and lack confidence to encourage or adopt them even where the parties believe a joint session would be helpful.
• Posturing: Easier to hide behind the mediator when the goal is to play tough at the mediation (especially court ordered) to set-up a better deal down the road.
• Bad facts, bad law or both: Joint sessions make tomfoolery more difficult.
In my experience, the time consuming and destructive scenarios feared by litigators reluctant to try joint sessions are rare. When managed by an experienced mediator comfortable with keeping the parties together, joint sessions can add great value to the process. If someone anticipates the process spinning out of control, they can always request return to the caucus model.
Joint sessions add value
There are many ways in which joint opening sessions, when properly managed, provide value and enhance the likelihood of a satisfactory resolution. Here are several ideas to consider:
• Studies show increased party satisfaction and a greater likelihood the agreement will be adhered to when the parties are involved directly in the process. Parties play a larger role in joint session than in caucus, which tends to be attorney oriented.
• In an era of “The Vanishing American Trial,” joint opening sessions provide the parties with the closest thing to “their day in court.”
• Joint sessions allow the parties to find common ground on which to build a satisfactory resolution.
• Joint sessions are a training ground to improve negotiation and persuasion skills.
• If the parties have any interest in a continuing relationship, relationship repair begins in joint session: employer-employee disputes, landlord-tenant conflicts, and buyer-seller transactions are just three examples that come to mind.
• Joint sessions are the only place where parties to a dispute are provided the opportunity to communicate directly with one another in a safe environment.
• The most effective apologies are those delivered directly and face-to-face.
• Shuttle diplomacy is an inefficient way to transfer information or explore risk. If the parties are in the same room together, they can answer and parry each other’s arguments directly and quickly. This also eliminates the risk that the mediator will communicate the wrong information.
• In joint session, each side can size up opposing parties and their counsel: are they persuasive, compelling, sympathetic, talented, reasonable, engaging?
• The same is true about evaluating and assessing the strengths and qualities of the advocates. Good lawyers know how to put their skills and assets on display; they know how to engage with the other side and talk sensibly.
• Cases do not settle unless both sides agree. In joint session, each side can make it’s pitch directly to the other in the most compelling and persuasive fashion. No matter how talented and well prepared the mediator, the parties and their lawyers are best suited to explain where they’re coming from and why resolution is in their interest.
• Brainstorming creative options is richest and most robust during joint sessions. Joint brainstorming sessions typically occur later in the mediation process.
• If a lawyer is an obstacle to resolution, in joint opening sessions arguments and explanations can be made directly to decision makers without being filtered through their attorney.
• When a party has a need to vent, speaking directly to the other side can be more constructive and beneficial than venting to the mediator so long as everyone is prepared for it.
• Where party credibility is at issue, joint sessions present an opportunity to make personal observations and make an informed judgment about who and what to believe.
• If a party has a visual aid or PowerPoint show to demonstrate solid preparation, sound arguments and compelling advocacy, a joint session provides the best forum to play it out.
• In joint opening sessions, which include both preliminary remarks and exchanges between the parties, each side can better assess the constellation of factors contributing to valuation for settlement.
• In a joint session, the parties are better able to recognize the needs and interests of the other side, which leads in turn to more tailored offers and counter-offers leading to WIN/WIN resolution.
• Unlike the results of cross examination in a deposition environment or an evidentiary hearing, the joint session permits each side to humanize their clients.
• When parties directly participate in a settlement process they reach more satisfactory resolution. When the resolution is satisfactory, parties rarely experience buyer’s remorse.
• Because so many disputes result from a failure to communicate, real breakthroughs may occur when the parties listen to one another and develop an understanding of their perspective.
• Richard Hurford,3 a long time respected litigator and corporate representative who attended hundreds of mediations, makes these additional points in favor of joint sessions:
• The best way to determine whether the other side is participating in the process in good faith is to see and hear with your own eyes and ears what words are used, how the words are used and how the other side responds in real time.
• Absent a joint session, it is impossible to pick up all the clues and messages the other side is trying to convey in each round as the mediator either filters what he or she hears or translates everything into the mediator’s own words. Nuance may be lost; important evidentiary points unappreciated by the mediator may be omitted; and the message could be garbled.
Joint sessions allow you to see the emotional trigger points and interests of the other side in ways the mediator could not and probably would not reveal. Reading the other side will have an impact on BATNA, WATNA and LATNA.
Common examples where joint sessions work well
One size does not fit all. There are as many reasons to consider a joint session as there are conflicts.
Here are a number of common situations where a joint session is likely to add value:
• One or both parties has a need to vent.
• An apology or acknowledgement is in order.
• The parties are looking for ways to repair their relationship because of a desire to work together, engage in a business venture or maintain peace where they will continue to encounter one another after the mediation is over.
• High level decision makers are present who understand each other and quickly get to the heart of the dispute.
• The parties are concerned their message is not being heard or understood because it is filtered through opposing counsel or the mediator.
• Common ground exists which can best be recognized when discussed openly and together.
• The parties don’t have all the facts – generally, discovery has not yet started – and prefer to ask questions of each other directly.
• There are issues of credibility – and each side would like to assess the credibility of the other more directly.
• The parties seek an opportunity to observe one other in action.
• Someone would like to see one or both of the litigators demonstrate their skills, finesse and talent.
• A party wants to observe the reaction of the other to certain statements or arguments.
• A participant believes he or she can articulate a key point better than anyone else at the table.
• The dispute is intractable and a joint brain-storming session to identify creative new options is in order.
Conclusion
Joint sessions have a bad rap. Lawyers fear escalating emotions, unscripted outbursts and unforeseen consequences, but have little actual experience with joint sessions managed by trained and experienced mediators. Joint sessions are not without risk, but by and large, the risk is minimal, the fears overstated. Instead, joint sessions hold promise and add value. The next time you’re planning to try mediation, I hope you will consider joint sessions. Building joint sessions into your process design might just make for a more efficient, effective and satisfying experience.
Footnotes:
1A version of this paper was originally prepared with Steven J. Barney, Petosky and Daniel P. O’Neil, Traverse City as coauthors for the 2015 ADR Section Annual Meeting.
2Mediators, of course, ask, “What trial is that?” Statistics from the State Court Administrative Office (SCAO) demonstrate that only 1.2 % of all cases filed in Michigan actually go to trial.
3Hurford now offers ADR services himself through Dispute Resolution Services PC.
————————
Sheldon J. Stark offers mediation and arbitration services. He is a member of the National Academy of Distinguished Neutrals, a Distinguished Fellow with the International Academy of Mediators and an Employment Law Panelist for the American Arbitration Association. He is also a member of the Professional Resolution Experts of Michigan (PREMi, https://premiadr.com). He is past chair of the council of the Alternative Dispute Resolution Section of the State Bar and formerly chaired the Skills Action Team. Stark was a distinguished visiting professor at the University of Detroit Mercy School of Law from August 2010 through May 2012, when he stepped down to focus on his ADR practice. Previously, he was employed by ICLE. He remains one of three trainers in ICLE’s award-winning 40-hour, hands-on civil mediation training. Before joining ICLE, Stark was a partner in the law firm of Stark and Gordon from 1977 to 1999, specializing in employment discrimination, wrongful discharge, civil rights, business litigation, and personal injury work.
Our Professionals
- Member Emeritus
Case Studies
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: online pharmacy in Mexico – purple pharmacy mexico price list
http://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/# medication from mexico pharmacy
world pharmacy india: Generic Medicine India to USA – best online pharmacy india
top 10 online pharmacy in india Online medicine home delivery Online medicine home delivery
repaglinide innovator
http://canadianpharmgrx.com/# canadian pharmacy king
buy cheap generic cleocin – buy acticlate without prescription cheap chloramphenicol generic
https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/# canadian family pharmacy
india pharmacy mail order: indian pharmacy – best india pharmacy
http://mexicanpharmgrx.com/# mexican drugstore online
world pharmacy india Online medicine home delivery buy prescription drugs from india
canadian pharmacy online ship to usa: Cheapest drug prices Canada – canadian pharmacy world
robaxin cost
how long does remeron stay in your system
http://mexicanpharmgrx.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
best online pharmacies in mexico: Mexico drugstore – mexican rx online
canadian online pharmacy Canada pharmacy online thecanadianpharmacy
https://canadianpharmgrx.com/# ed drugs online from canada
protonix drug interactions
india pharmacy mail order: indian pharmacy – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs Pills from Mexican Pharmacy mexico drug stores pharmacies
buy prescription drugs from india: india pharmacy – indian pharmacy online
buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/# cheapest pharmacy canada
azithromycin online order – ciplox over the counter ciprofloxacin 500mg over the counter
https://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
reputable indian online pharmacy: Generic Medicine India to USA – india pharmacy mail order
trusted canadian pharmacy: International Pharmacy delivery – canada drugs online reviews
canadian pharmacy meds reviews Cheapest drug prices Canada canadian pharmacy service
http://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/# canadian drugs online
mexican rx online Pills from Mexican Pharmacy mexican rx online
top 10 online pharmacy in india: Generic Medicine India to USA – buy medicines online in india
https://indianpharmgrx.com/# buy medicines online in india
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican pharmacy – mexican drugstore online
https://canadianpharmgrx.com/# canadian pharmacy online reviews
mexico drug stores pharmacies medication from mexico pharmacy medicine in mexico pharmacies
purple pharmacy mexico price list: Mexico drugstore – best online pharmacies in mexico
buy generic ciprofloxacin: buy generic ciprofloxacin – purchase cipro
cipro ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price buy cipro cheap
cipro online no prescription in the usa: cipro pharmacy – cipro 500mg best prices
cytotec abortion pill: Misoprostol 200 mg buy online – buy cytotec over the counter
purchase cytotec: buy cytotec over the counter – Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
tamoxifen for gynecomastia reviews tamoxifen and bone density tamoxifen dose
https://doxycyclinest.pro/# doxycycline 50 mg
cipro ciprofloxacin: antibiotics cipro – cipro 500mg best prices
buy cytotec over the counter buy cytotec pills online cheap purchase cytotec
cipro pharmacy: ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online – cipro online no prescription in the usa
doxycycline hyc 100mg: doxylin – price of doxycycline
buy misoprostol over the counter: order cytotec online – buy cytotec online
diflucan candida: diflucan 100 – how to get diflucan online
buy cytotec over the counter Cytotec 200mcg price buy cytotec over the counter
where can i buy diflucan without a prescription: can i purchase diflucan over the counter – buy diflucan prescription med
buy cytotec over the counter buy cytotec online fast delivery cytotec abortion pill
cytotec online: cytotec abortion pill – order cytotec online
https://nolvadex.icu/# where to get nolvadex
purchase albuterol inhaler – fluticasone canada buy theophylline 400mg online cheap
tamoxifen pill tamoxifen hair loss nolvadex estrogen blocker
purchase cipro: ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online – where can i buy cipro online
common side effects of tamoxifen: does tamoxifen cause bone loss – how does tamoxifen work
buy ivermectin pills – order cefaclor 250mg online cheap cefaclor 500mg cheap
arimidex vs tamoxifen bodybuilding: how to get nolvadex – buy tamoxifen
ciprofloxacin mail online cipro pharmacy cipro online no prescription in the usa
Abortion pills online: buy cytotec over the counter – buy cytotec pills
buy diflucan without prescription: diflucan drug coupon – diflucan 200
diflucan 150 mg price uk diflucan prices canada diflucan 2 pills
100mg doxycycline: doxylin – doxycycline generic
https://ciprofloxacin.guru/# ciprofloxacin generic
diflucan 110 mg: over the counter diflucan 150 – buy diflucan online
cheap doxycycline online doxycycline 200 mg doxycycline 50mg
tamoxifen mechanism of action: tamoxifen vs clomid – alternative to tamoxifen
diflucan for sale online: diflucan 400mg without prescription – where to buy diflucan otc
diflucan 100: generic diflucan 150 mg – diflucan 200 mg price south africa
order diflucan online generic for diflucan buy diflucan without script
tamoxifen buy: tamoxifen 20 mg tablet – tamoxifen menopause
doxycycline pills: doxycycline 200 mg – doxylin
buy cytotec pills: buy cytotec over the counter – purchase cytotec
cytotec abortion pill buy cytotec buy cytotec over the counter
zithromax pill: zithromax 500 mg lowest price online – how to get zithromax over the counter
http://prednisonea.store/# prednisone price australia
amoxicillin 500 mg capsule cost of amoxicillin amoxicillin 500mg pill
stromectol 6 mg tablet: stromectol 3 mg tablets price – ivermectin 3mg tablets price
buy ivermectin stromectol: ivermectin 3mg for lice – ivermectin 90 mg
buy generic zithromax online buy zithromax online fast shipping zithromax online australia
can i buy cheap clomid without dr prescription: can i buy generic clomid without a prescription – where buy clomid
repaglinide effet secondaire
amoxicillin 500mg for sale uk: purchase amoxicillin 500 mg – amoxicillin medicine
https://azithromycina.pro/# zithromax generic cost
zithromax buy: zithromax online pharmacy canada – generic zithromax medicine
buy generic clarinex – buy clarinex 5mg without prescription albuterol 2mg drug
generic zithromax medicine: zithromax 500mg price in india – zithromax 250mg
https://azithromycina.pro/# zithromax for sale usa
http://prednisonea.store/# non prescription prednisone 20mg
zithromax 250 mg australia: zithromax 1000 mg pills – zithromax 500 mg for sale
sitagliptin xelevia 50mg
buy zithromax online australia zithromax for sale online zithromax over the counter canada
zithromax for sale us: zithromax for sale usa – zithromax cost canada
http://amoxicillina.top/# buy cheap amoxicillin
buy zithromax online: buy zithromax without presc – where can i buy zithromax medicine
how to get zithromax zithromax tablets zithromax cost uk
zithromax 250 price: can i buy zithromax over the counter in canada – zithromax cost uk
https://prednisonea.store/# prednisone acetate
can i buy clomid without prescription: buying clomid – can i get clomid without prescription
synthroid fainting
zithromax purchase online: zithromax order online uk – zithromax 500mg
spironolactone kidney side effects
get ed meds online: cheapest erectile dysfunction pills – cheapest online ed meds
online pharmacy discount code canadian pharmacy world coupon rx pharmacy coupons
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# no prescription needed online pharmacy
methylprednisolone tablets – purchase fml-forte generic astelin brand
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# canada prescription drugs online
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# canadian pharmacy world coupon code
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# cheapest pharmacy for prescriptions without insurance
low cost ed medication: where can i buy ed pills – boner pills online
discount ed meds cheap ed generic ed meds online
no prescription drugs: buy medication online without prescription – canada mail order prescription
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# cheap pharmacy no prescription
pharmacy discount coupons: cheap pharmacy no prescription – pharmacy online 365 discount code
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions with insurance
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# pharmacy without prescription
http://medicationnoprescription.pro/# canada pharmacy without prescription
ed online prescription: online erectile dysfunction pills – buy ed meds
http://edpill.top/# online ed medicine
canadian pharmacy discount coupon canadian pharmacy no prescription needed online pharmacy no prescription
https://edpill.top/# best online ed medication
no prescription medication: medications online without prescription – buy prescription drugs online without
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# best online pharmacy that does not require a prescription in india
order micronase 5mg pills – buy cheap dapagliflozin forxiga cost
cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions without insurance: canadian pharmacy world coupons – canadian pharmacy world coupon
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# rx pharmacy no prescription
online pharmacy no prescriptions prescription meds from canada prescription drugs online canada
https://casinvietnam.com/# game c? b?c online uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: game c? b?c online uy tín – dánh bài tr?c tuy?n
http://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam web c? b?c online uy tin danh bai tr?c tuy?n
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i
voltaren gel website
http://casinvietnam.com/# choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i
web c? b?c online uy tin casino online uy tin casino tr?c tuy?n
Sau khi làm theo những yêu cầu trên thì đối tượng lại báo là sai số tài khoản nhận tiền vay và yêu cầu chị P. chuyển tiếp một khoản tiền nữa để khắc phục lỗi thì mới giải ngân được. Sau 11 lần chuyển khoản với tổng số tiền là 308 triệu đồng mà theo lời đối tượng là để sửa các lỗi như sai số tài khoản, sai nội dung, đóng phí bảo hiểm… chị P. vẫn không nhận được khoản tiền vay nào trong khi đối tượng đã cắt đứt hoàn toàn liên lạc… Khách hàng cần chứng minh có thu nhập ổn định thông qua hợp đồng lao động (có hiệu lực) với sao kê lương (bản gốc) từ 3-6 tháng gần nhất. Ngân hàng sẽ xem xét mức thu nhập của người đi vay với số tiền cho vay để đánh giá khả năng chi trả nợ. Bên cạnh đó, một số ngân hàng còn bổ sung thêm những điều kiện khác nhau.
https://jaredrndo557024.tinyblogging.com/%C4%91i%E1%BB%81u-ki%E1%BB%87n-%C4%91%E1%BB%83-vay-ng%C3%A2n-h%C3%A0ng-ch%C3%ADnh-s%C3%A1ch-65364213
Không chỉ là hộ gia đình vay vốn của ngân hàng, ông Tần còn làm Tổ trưởng Tổ vay vốn của xã Ayun Hạ để làm cầu nối giữa người dân với ngân hàng. Hiện Tổ vay vốn có 16 hộ gia đình tham gia, trong đó người được vay cao nhất khoảng 200 triệu đồng. Vay tín chấp theo lương chuyển khoảny lên tới 15 lần lương, số tiền vay lên tới 900 triệu không cần thế chấp tài sản, lãi suất ưu đãi từ 0,6 tháng, Thủ tục đơn giản, thời gian giải ngân trong ngày. Với điều kiện vay đơn giản khi mức thu nhập từ 5 triệu tháng. Để tính được số tiền phải trả mỗi tháng khi vay ngân hàng 200 triệu trong 10 năm, bạn cần biết công thức tính lãi suất vay ngân hàng. Có hai cách tính lãi vay ngân hàng phổ biến là theo dư nợ gốc và theo dư nợ giảm dần.
venlafaxine side effects sexually female
tamsulosin esparma 0.4 mg rek preisvergleich
casino tr?c tuy?n: choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i – casino tr?c tuy?n
tizanidine dosage
casino online uy tín: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – casino tr?c tuy?n
dánh bài tr?c tuy?n: casino tr?c tuy?n – choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i
https://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
repaglinide 2mg cheap – buy jardiance paypal empagliflozin price
choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i: casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín – game c? b?c online uy tín
https://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: game c? b?c online uy tín – casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
casino tr?c tuy?n: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – casino tr?c tuy?n
choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i danh bai tr?c tuy?n
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín – web c? b?c online uy tín
https://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
game c? b?c online uy tin casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin casino online uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n: casino online uy tín – casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín
Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?
https://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
http://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n
casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin casino online uy tin game c? b?c online uy tin
game c? b?c online uy tín: casino online uy tín – casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
https://casinvietnam.shop/# game c? b?c online uy tin
casino online uy tin web c? b?c online uy tin game c? b?c online uy tin
加强隐私保护,选择Telegram中文版 – 安全、快速、可靠https://www.telegramzw.com
vyrexzbton
dánh bài tr?c tuy?n: casino tr?c tuy?n – web c? b?c online uy tín
glycomet for sale online – hyzaar online order buy precose pills for sale
zetia pricing
game c? b?c online uy tin game c? b?c online uy tin casino online uy tin
https://casinvietnam.shop/# game c? b?c online uy tin
http://casinvietnam.com/# choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i
casino tr?c tuy?n: dánh bài tr?c tuy?n – casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
https://casinvietnam.com/# choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i
casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín: casino tr?c tuy?n – casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín
medication from mexico pharmacy cheapest mexico drugs buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://canadaph24.pro/# www canadianonlinepharmacy
Online medicine home delivery indian pharmacy indian pharmacy online
http://indiaph24.store/# best online pharmacy india
https://indiaph24.store/# indian pharmacy online
Online medicine home delivery Generic Medicine India to USA best online pharmacy india
canada online pharmacy: buying drugs from canada – best canadian pharmacy online
https://mexicoph24.life/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
wellbutrin sr vs wellbutrin xl forums
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican rx online
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexico pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
zyprexa seroquel
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico pharmacy
canada rx pharmacy Large Selection of Medications from Canada canadian pharmacy scam
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian 24 hour pharmacy
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
is zofran and ativan compatible
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india Generic Medicine India to USA mail order pharmacy india
legit canadian online pharmacy Certified Canadian Pharmacies canadian pharmacy antibiotics
http://indiaph24.store/# top 10 online pharmacy in india
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
medication from mexico pharmacy Online Pharmacies in Mexico mexican rx online
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican mail order pharmacies
best online canadian pharmacy Large Selection of Medications from Canada canada drugs reviews
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
http://indiaph24.store/# indian pharmacy
top online pharmacy india world pharmacy india buy medicines online in india
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
medicine in mexico pharmacies Mexican Pharmacy Online mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy online
mexico drug stores pharmacies: Mexican Pharmacy Online – buying from online mexican pharmacy
http://canadaph24.pro/# cheapest pharmacy canada
buy terbinafine sale – buy generic fluconazole online grifulvin v canada
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india buy medicines from India п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
https://mexicoph24.life/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexican pharmacy purple pharmacy mexico price list
http://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy
http://canadaph24.pro/# canada online pharmacy
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies cheapest mexico drugs mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
pharmacy website india: indian pharmacy fast delivery – top 10 pharmacies in india
https://indiaph24.store/# cheapest online pharmacy india
mexican pharmacy Online Pharmacies in Mexico buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://mexicoph24.life/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
mexican rx online mexican pharmacy buying from online mexican pharmacy
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy king
medication from mexico pharmacy cheapest mexico drugs medicine in mexico pharmacies
medication from mexico pharmacy: Mexican Pharmacy Online – mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy com
escrow pharmacy canada Licensed Canadian Pharmacy canada drugs online reviews
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian family pharmacy
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican drugstore online
reputable canadian online pharmacy Prescription Drugs from Canada canada rx pharmacy
https://canadaph24.pro/# vipps approved canadian online pharmacy
cheapest online pharmacy india: Cheapest online pharmacy – Online medicine order
indian pharmacy paypal indian pharmacy online shopping pharmacy india
https://canadaph24.pro/# best canadian online pharmacy
https://indiaph24.store/# buy prescription drugs from india
canadian pharmacy 365 canadian pharmacies reliable canadian pharmacy reviews
alcohol and zyprexa
https://mexicoph24.life/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
india pharmacy mail order indian pharmacy indian pharmacies safe
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
rybelsus 14 mg drug – glucovance oral purchase desmopressin spray
canada pharmacy online Certified Canadian Pharmacies reliable canadian pharmacy reviews
zofran severe constipation
http://canadaph24.pro/# canada ed drugs
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
mail order pharmacy india indian pharmacy Online medicine home delivery
http://canadaph24.pro/# canada rx pharmacy
top 10 pharmacies in india buy medicines from India Online medicine order
https://canadaph24.pro/# my canadian pharmacy review
https://canadaph24.pro/# trusted canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy Licensed Canadian Pharmacy canadian valley pharmacy
http://mexicoph24.life/# best online pharmacies in mexico
reputable indian pharmacies: indian pharmacy – india online pharmacy
https://mexicoph24.life/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
online pharmacy india mail order pharmacy india top online pharmacy india
https://indiaph24.store/# pharmacy website india
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs cheapest mexico drugs mexican rx online
http://indiaph24.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
legit canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacy 24h com safe
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://indiaph24.store/# Online medicine order
order nizoral generic – sporanox 100 mg for sale itraconazole 100 mg over the counter
buying prescription drugs in mexico online Mexican Pharmacy Online buying prescription drugs in mexico
https://mexicoph24.life/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
trustworthy canadian pharmacy: Large Selection of Medications from Canada – canadian pharmacy meds
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexico pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://indiaph24.store/# world pharmacy india
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican mail order pharmacies
pharmacy website india indian pharmacy Online medicine order
http://mexicoph24.life/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://indiaph24.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
india pharmacy Cheapest online pharmacy top online pharmacy india
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy 1 internet online drugstore
certified canadian pharmacy: Licensed Canadian Pharmacy – legitimate canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy world Prescription Drugs from Canada best canadian pharmacy to order from
http://indiaph24.store/# online pharmacy india
mexican pharmacy cheapest mexico drugs purple pharmacy mexico price list
http://canadaph24.pro/# prescription drugs canada buy online
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexican pharmacy buying from online mexican pharmacy
http://mexicoph24.life/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican mail order pharmacies mexican pharmacy medicine in mexico pharmacies
canadian discount pharmacy: Prescription Drugs from Canada – canadian pharmacy 24h com safe
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
indianpharmacy com reputable indian online pharmacy online pharmacy india
https://indiaph24.store/# world pharmacy india
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy com
indian pharmacies safe indian pharmacy fast delivery reputable indian pharmacies
https://indiaph24.store/# buy medicines online in india
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexican drugstore online
http://indiaph24.store/# buy prescription drugs from india
mexican drugstore online Online Pharmacies in Mexico п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
top online pharmacy india: Cheapest online pharmacy – reputable indian pharmacies
http://canadaph24.pro/# prescription drugs canada buy online
http://canadaph24.pro/# legit canadian online pharmacy
buying from online mexican pharmacy Mexican Pharmacy Online mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy 365
indian pharmacies safe Cheapest online pharmacy top 10 pharmacies in india
http://indiaph24.store/# п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
mexico pharmacy: Online Pharmacies in Mexico – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican drugstore online: cheapest mexico drugs – reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian family pharmacy
india pharmacy http://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy mail order
buy prescription drugs from india
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexico pharmacy – purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican rx online mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy 24h com safe Prescription Drugs from Canada canadian pharmacy price checker
lanoxin 250 mg drug – buy digoxin 250mg generic purchase furosemide online cheap
http://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy
https://indiaph24.store/# reputable indian online pharmacy
top 10 pharmacies in india https://indiaph24.store/# best online pharmacy india
india online pharmacy
order famciclovir 500mg generic – valaciclovir generic valcivir for sale online
https://mexicoph24.life/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
https://finasteride.store/# cost cheap propecia without prescription
https://nolvadex.life/# what happens when you stop taking tamoxifen
http://lisinopril.network/# 3 lisinopril
lisinopril 5 mg canada: 208 lisinopril – zestril no prescription
tamoxifen and depression nolvadex 20mg nolvadex d
ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price buy cipro online canada buy cipro cheap
buy cytotec online: buy cytotec in usa – cytotec abortion pill
https://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 100 mg
http://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec pills
cipro 500mg best prices ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online
lisinopril online 50mg lisinopril lisinopril 2.5 cost
ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online: cipro – ciprofloxacin mail online
https://cytotec.club/# Cytotec 200mcg price
generic propecia without insurance: home – how cÉ‘n i get cheap propecia pills
https://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 20 25 mg tab
tamoxifen for men tamoxifen rash pictures tamoxifen joint pain
ciprofloxacin generic purchase cipro buy ciprofloxacin
https://finasteride.store/# cost generic propecia without dr prescription
buy cytotec: cytotec pills buy online – cytotec pills online
https://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen for gynecomastia reviews
generic tamoxifen tamoxifen adverse effects liquid tamoxifen
ciprofloxacin generic price ciprofloxacin order online purchase cipro
ciprofloxacin over the counter: ciprofloxacin generic – buy cipro
http://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec
http://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 10 mg online
http://finasteride.store/# cost cheap propecia without prescription
lisinopril 20: lisinopril india – generic prinivil
buy cipro online canada buy cipro online ciprofloxacin generic
lisinopril canada lisinopril 10mg tablets lisinopril tab 100mg
buy cytotec over the counter: buy cytotec over the counter – buy cytotec over the counter
https://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec over the counter
http://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 20 mg tablet
Cytotec 200mcg price: cytotec abortion pill – buy cytotec online fast delivery
buying cheap propecia without dr prescription cost of generic propecia tablets buy generic propecia without insurance
buy misoprostol over the counter buy cytotec online fast delivery buy cytotec
http://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen and osteoporosis
http://finasteride.store/# buy generic propecia without insurance
Abortion pills online: cytotec buy online usa – buy cytotec over the counter
hydrochlorothiazide us – buy generic bisoprolol zebeta generic
https://lisinopril.network/# 10 mg lisinopril tablets
cost of propecia tablets get generic propecia without dr prescription propecia online
lisinopril 30 mg: prinivil brand name – lisinopril 40mg prescription cost
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# ciprofloxacin order online
antibiotics cipro buy generic ciprofloxacin where can i buy cipro online
https://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 5 mg tablet cost
generic propecia price: cheap propecia price – buy generic propecia without prescription
https://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec in usa
lisinopril 80 zestril 25 mg lipinpril
what is tamoxifen used for clomid nolvadex nolvadex vs clomid
cytotec pills online: buy cytotec – buy cytotec
https://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec over the counter
https://finasteride.store/# cheap propecia without prescription
low dose tamoxifen: tamoxifen 20 mg – tamoxifen for breast cancer prevention
tamoxifen hair loss tamoxifen citrate tamoxifen menopause
https://nolvadex.life/# nolvadex only pct
tamoxifen and weight loss: tamoxifen and grapefruit – tamoxifen premenopausal
https://cytotec.club/# Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
where to get nolvadex how to lose weight on tamoxifen nolvadex during cycle
cost of generic propecia for sale buying propecia order cheap propecia no prescription
https://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec over the counter
tamoxifen depression: tamoxifen skin changes – aromatase inhibitor tamoxifen
https://finasteride.store/# get propecia
buy cipro online: cipro pharmacy – buy cipro cheap
buy metoprolol 100mg – micardis ca nifedipine sale
nolvadex half life clomid nolvadex tamoxifen 20 mg tablet
cytotec buy online usa buy cytotec pills buy misoprostol over the counter
http://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen hip pain
buy cytotec pills online cheap: Cytotec 200mcg price – cytotec pills online
http://nolvadex.life/# buy tamoxifen
https://nolvadex.life/# raloxifene vs tamoxifen
buy cytotec online fast delivery: buy cytotec – buy cytotec over the counter
buy misoprostol over the counter cytotec online Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
prinivil price prinivil tabs zestoretic 20 12.5
cialis levitra viagra
https://finasteride.store/# cost cheap propecia prices
https://finasteride.store/# propecia tablets
zestril coupon: lisinopril 60 mg daily – lisinopril 20 mg best price
https://finasteride.store/# cheap propecia without prescription
how to get nolvadex: tamoxifen breast cancer – tamoxifen premenopausal
cipro pharmacy antibiotics cipro ciprofloxacin over the counter
lisinopril 15mg prinivil online 208 lisinopril
nitroglycerin pill – combipres online buy diovan tablets
https://cenforce.pro/# buy cenforce
https://cenforce.pro/# Buy Cenforce 100mg Online
п»їkamagra: kamagra oral jelly – Kamagra 100mg price
Sildenafil Citrate Tablets 100mg: Buy Viagra online cheap – Viagra online price
https://levitrav.store/# buy Levitra over the counter
Buy Cenforce 100mg Online Cenforce 100mg tablets for sale Buy Cenforce 100mg Online
levitra buy cheap
Cheap generic Viagra online Cheapest place to buy Viagra Sildenafil 100mg price
cialis on line purchase
Generic Viagra for sale: buy Viagra online – Sildenafil 100mg price
cheap viagra: Buy Viagra online cheap – cheap viagra
http://cialist.pro/# Cheap Cialis
http://kamagra.win/# Kamagra 100mg
https://viagras.online/# Cheap generic Viagra
Cheap Cialis: buy cialis overseas – Cialis 20mg price
Kamagra tablets kamagra pills Kamagra tablets
tadalafil professional review
Levitra 10 mg best price Buy Vardenafil 20mg Cheap Levitra online
http://viagras.online/# Viagra generic over the counter
Cenforce 150 mg online: Purchase Cenforce Online – Purchase Cenforce Online
http://cialist.pro/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg
Buy Vardenafil online Levitra 20mg price Cheap Levitra online
http://cialist.pro/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg
buy kamagra online usa: kamagra.win – Kamagra 100mg price
cenforce.pro Buy Cenforce 100mg Online buy cenforce
Kamagra tablets: buy kamagra online usa – Kamagra tablets
http://levitrav.store/# Cheap Levitra online
探索Telegram中文版的无限可能 – 一个安全、快捷、多功能的即时通讯平台。无论是文件分享、群组聊天还是机器人互动,Telegram都能满足您的需求。快来体验安全通讯的新时代。Explore the endless possibilities with Telegram Chinese Version – a secure, fast, and feature-rich instant messaging platform. Whether it’s file sharing, group chats, or bot interactions, Telegram meets all your needs. Experience a new era of secure communication.https://www.telegram-apk.com
gtijhomkgm
order viagra: Buy Viagra online – buy Viagra over the counter
https://cenforce.pro/# order cenforce
Cheap generic Viagra Cheapest Sildenafil online Generic Viagra for sale
п»їBuy generic 100mg Viagra online viagras.online Generic Viagra online
Viagra Tablet price: Buy Viagra online cheap – sildenafil over the counter
https://cialist.pro/# cialis for sale
Kamagra 100mg price: kamagra.win – kamagra
http://viagras.online/# Cheap generic Viagra
http://kamagra.win/# Kamagra tablets
Levitra 10 mg buy online Buy generic Levitra online Cheap Levitra online
cenforce for sale: cenforce for sale – Buy Cenforce 100mg Online
Kamagra 100mg price kamagra Kamagra 100mg price
http://cialist.pro/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg
Cialis over the counter: Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription – Cialis 20mg price in USA
https://viagras.online/# Cheap generic Viagra online
Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription: buy cialis online – п»їcialis generic
buy viagra here Buy Viagra online cheap Cheapest Sildenafil online
Kamagra tablets kamagra oral jelly Kamagra 100mg
best price for viagra 100mg: Cheap Viagra 100mg – Viagra generic over the counter
http://levitrav.store/# Buy Vardenafil 20mg
http://kamagra.win/# Kamagra Oral Jelly
Buy Levitra 20mg online: Vardenafil buy online – Buy Vardenafil 20mg online
Unlock the full potential of your digital assets with imToken. Fast, secure, and user-friendly – the ultimate crypto wallet. | 用imToken释放您数字资产的全部潜力。快速、安全、用户友好——终极加密钱包。https://www.imtokend.com
hekdoly3vr
http://kamagra.win/# Kamagra 100mg price
https://kamagra.win/# buy kamagra online usa
https://pharmcanada.shop/# canadian pharmacy 1 internet online drugstore
https://pharmworld.store/# mail order pharmacy no prescription
medication from mexico pharmacy: best online pharmacies in mexico – medication from mexico pharmacy
canadian pharmacy mall: canadian pharmacy meds reviews – canadian neighbor pharmacy
no prescription canadian pharmacy: no prescription on line pharmacies – canadian prescription prices
online pharmacy without prescription pharm world store overseas pharmacy no prescription
https://pharmcanada.shop/# canada drugs online reviews
non prescription pharmacy online prescription canada no prescription needed
canadianpharmacymeds: best canadian pharmacy to buy from – best online canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription: pharm world store – canada pharmacy coupon
https://pharmmexico.online/# mexico pharmacy
http://pharmnoprescription.icu/# cheap prescription drugs online
online pharmacy india: best india pharmacy – mail order pharmacy india
mexican prescription drugs online mexican pharmacy no prescription canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
buying prescription drugs from canada online order prescription from canada buy meds online no prescription
crestor fire – crestor online count caduet nobody
canadian drugs online: canadian pharmacy meds – reputable canadian online pharmacy
best online pharmacy india: indian pharmacy – buy prescription drugs from india
http://pharmworld.store/# prescription drugs from canada
Online medicine home delivery buy medicines online in india mail order pharmacy india
http://pharmindia.online/# india pharmacy
world pharmacy india п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india mail order pharmacy india
reputable indian pharmacies: indian pharmacy online – reputable indian online pharmacy
the canadian drugstore: canadian drugstore online – best canadian pharmacy to buy from
mail order pharmacy india: indian pharmacy – mail order pharmacy india
online shopping pharmacy india: top 10 pharmacies in india – mail order pharmacy india
https://pharmcanada.shop/# northwest pharmacy canada
cheapest online pharmacy india world pharmacy india reputable indian pharmacies
buy prescription drugs from india best india pharmacy reputable indian pharmacies
https://pharmworld.store/# offshore pharmacy no prescription
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexico drug stores pharmacies
canadianpharmacymeds: canadian pharmacy online – canadian world pharmacy
no prescription canadian pharmacies: online canadian pharmacy no prescription – canadian rx prescription drugstore
http://pharmnoprescription.icu/# canadian prescription prices
buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian drugstore online legal canadian pharmacy online legit canadian pharmacy
canadian drugs pharmacy online canadian pharmacy review canada rx pharmacy
http://pharmnoprescription.icu/# canada drugs no prescription
prescription drugs canada buy online: pharmacies in canada that ship to the us – legitimate canadian pharmacy
https://pharmcanada.shop/# pharmacy canadian superstore
pharmacy discount coupons: pharm world store – international pharmacy no prescription
top 10 online pharmacy in india: reputable indian pharmacies – top 10 online pharmacy in india
http://pharmnoprescription.icu/# buying drugs online no prescription
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexico drug stores pharmacies purple pharmacy mexico price list
https://pharmcanada.shop/# canada drugstore pharmacy rx
drugs from canada: canadianpharmacymeds – canadian medications
canada online prescription buying prescription drugs online canada buy drugs online without a prescription
http://pharmnoprescription.icu/# pharmacy online no prescription
oral zocor 10mg – fenofibrate stain lipitor pant
prednisone pills 10 mg: prednisone 1 tablet – prednisone buy
online doxycycline: buy cheap doxycycline online – doxycycline 100mg dogs
doxycycline generic: doxycycline vibramycin – buy cheap doxycycline online
zithromax cost australia zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online how to buy zithromax online
40 mg daily prednisone prednisone pill 10 mg 20 mg prednisone tablet
https://prednisoned.online/# best pharmacy prednisone
cheap doxycycline online: 200 mg doxycycline – buy doxycycline online without prescription
http://amoxila.pro/# buy amoxicillin 250mg
amoxicillin online canada: amoxil pharmacy – where can i buy amoxicillin online
how to get prednisone tablets: where can i buy prednisone online without a prescription – prednisone online for sale
prednisone brand name: prednisone 12 tablets price – prednisone for cheap