Robert E. L. Wright
Online Dispute Resolution (“ODR”) may refer to any form of alternative dispute resolution conducted with the aid of a computer. Two in particular, mediation and arbitration, are proceeded by a variety of adjectives: Remote; Virtual; Cloud; Videoconference; etc. Here, ODR will refer specifically to mediations and arbitrations conducted by videoconference without actual face-to-face, in-person meetings. (Whenever information would pertain equally to mediation or arbitration, the term mediation is used.)
Aspects of ODR have been with us in one form another for decades. ODR includes a variety of remote dispute resolution mechanisms, from negotiations by telephone and email, to arbitrations conducted without any witnesses based on documents supplied via email or facsimile. But arbitrations and mediations conducted exclusively via videoconferencing are the subject of this article.
The Case for and Against ODR (with Rebuttal)
Traditionally, both mediation and arbitration have been conducted almost exclusively in face-to-face meetings. Yes, some processes are held with one or more participants appearing by phone or videoconference, but those are most often exceptions, not the rule.
Early forms of ODR have been around for the past few decades. However, until videoconferencing became affordable and ubiquitous, most such ODR processes involved a simple typed exchange of monetary settlement offers and counteroffers through an impersonal platform; Party A typing in an offer and Party B typing in a counteroffer, then rinse and repeat until reaching a settlement or declaring an impasse. Enter free (or nearly free) video conferencing via Skype, Facebook, Google Duo, Go To Meeting, WebEx and Zoom, etc. and ODR becomes virtual reality.
Although there are many platforms for videoconferencing the favorite of mediators and most American courts is now Zoom. As noted above, Zoom provides free software for virtually any device and is extremely simple to use, both for hosts and guests. Using ODR platforms such as Zoom, neutrals now convene and conduct their virtual dispute resolution processes completely by videoconference. The form and substance of such processes mirror those of a traditional session conducted in person. The neutral or a provider organization schedules and “hosts” the process with parties and counsel attending as the host’s “guests.” Agreements can be signed remotely using DocuSign and similar services.
Safety & Social Distancing
With the advent of Zoom, ODR has been able to step up its game to rival a virtual face-to-face meeting with the added benefit of not having to inhale the same air or touch the other participants or any objects they touched in the mediation suite. With ODR, there is zero chance of contracting a virus from another participant when you can stay isolated in your own home or office yet still see and hear one another almost as if you were together in the same room. While you lose view of their feet and olfactory information (can you smell deception?), you can still observe upper body language, facial expressions (focusing on them at will), tone of voice, nervous tics and tells, and signs of anxiety, all of which conveys most of the information we would obtain in person.
Currently, COVID-19 is an extremely contagious and sometimes lethal coronavirus pandemic affecting the entire world. It appears the principal way the virus spreads is via human-to-human contact, especially through inhalation of the virus from a human carrier. As of this writing, there is no known cure and no proven vaccine to protect people from contracting the virus. As such, reducing human-to-human contact has proven effective in slowing the spread of the disease, but has crippled the economy and the ability of litigants to resolve their disputes through trial or alternative dispute resolution.
As the majority of Michigan mediators are nearing or over 60 years old, they are in a vulnerable group of Americans most likely to succumb to the effects of a virus. As such, many of our most experienced and effective neutrals are afraid of participating in face-to-face meetings for fear of contracting a fatal disease or, worse, bringing it home to a family member of like age and possibly poorer health. Most are willing to continue serving as neutrals if they can do so using ODR, but will stop hosting face-to-face hearings and retire altogether if their only choice is to expose themselves and their loved ones to a deadly disease. To preserve that pool of wonderful talent, ODR may be the only option.
Abusive Behavior
Another benefit of ODR is that it eliminates the possibility of physical violence occurring on the property of the attorney or mediator where the dispute resolution process is being conducted. Videoconferencing makes it easier for family mediators to conduct Michigan’s mandatory domestic violence screening with the parties separately, to assess their respective ability to negotiate and make decisions out of self-determination rather than fear. Indeed, inviting each spouse to a private session to check out the technology, provides cover for the mediator to conduct the screening discreetly.
Convenience
The convenience factor is obvious: no issues with transportation, parking, security checkpoints in courthouses, flight delays/cancellations/departure times, etc. It makes it far easier to schedule a mediation when flight times are not a factor. With ODR, the commute may simply be the time it takes to get from the kitchen to the room where the computer is located.
Cost Savings
Obviously, reduced travel time for attorneys translates to a reduction in fees billed to clients. ODR eliminates charges for rental cars, parking, mileage, plane tickets, meals, and hotel rooms. Most neutrals provide the ODR platform without charge and free versions of most software platforms is available to participants, though not hosts.
Specifically, Zoom provides a free version of its software with unlimited one-on-one meeting time, but only 40 minutes of time per session for meetings with three or more attendees. This allows parties and attorneys an opportunity to try the software with one another, friends or family members free of charge, which also reduces time spent on tech issues during the mediation if participants have already installed and used the software.
Promotes Better Behavior by Participants
In my experience, ODR reduces disruptive behavior with name-calling and angry outbursts; people just seem to behave more civilly on videocasts than they do in person. Particularly in mediation, there is less resistance to doing work in a joint session as opposed to a private meeting or “caucus,” which also saves time and promotes efficiency resulting in reduced professional fees charged to the parties.
Privacy & Confidentiality Concerns
There have been a few instances of “Zoom-bombing,” where uninvited internet trolls gained access to Zoom sessions and posted racist, sexist and pornographic messages and images. This primarily involved large groups, shared passwords (or no passwords) and wide dissemination of access information. I am not aware of a single instance of an uninvited guest gatecrashing a Zoom mediation or arbitration. Moreover, upon learning of this issue, Zoom responded with four tools available to all meeting hosts; a must for neutrals.
1. Meeting ID & Password. Hosts for each Zoom mediation assign a unique meeting ID and password required to gain access to the mediation. While they can be shared with unauthorized users, there are three more hurdles for a would be gatecrasher to overcome.
2. Waiting Room. The waiting room keeps gatecrashers from entering a mediation. Once inputting the confidential meeting ID and password, guests enter a virtual waiting room where they are held incommunicado in a virtual “cone of silence.” They will remain there until the host admits them to the mediation. The host can then eject or admit the guest to the main meeting room without allowing the new guest to have any contact with other attendees until a legitimate purpose for their presence is established. (E.g., an attorney substituting for a colleague.)
3. Close Meeting. Once all required participants have been admitted, the mediator will “close the door” to the mediation, barring any further admissions.
4. Private Rooms. Zoom neutrals may create up to 50 private Zoom conference rooms plus the main conference room and choose which guests to admit to each one. Initially, upon admission to the main room I put all guests into private rooms with their counsel. I say hello and introduce myself in each private room before beginning the actual settlement negotiations. This way, even if some rogue is briefly admitted to the (empty) main meeting room, they cannot communicate with another guest before I eject them.
Access to each private room is restricted to the host and only those guests the host chooses. Guests in private room can only see, hear and communicate with other guests in the same room, although they can summon the host when needed. The only exception to this absolute privacy is that the host can send a broadcast chat message to ALL PARTICIPANTS simultaneously. (The message is only visible for a few seconds and then disappears. I have requested that Zoom permit the host to communicate with any participant, no matter where they are located, but with the current volume of support requests, it may be a while before I receive a response.)
Collectively, these four security features should allay any fears concerning privacy and confidentiality for participants.
Data Privacy Concerns
Zoom collects and stores some personal data during mediations, including stored content in cloud recordings (but not information stored on the neutral’s computer), chat messages, shared files and whiteboards used during meetings. However, I am aware of no evidence of a breach to date. Some contact information was once shared with Facebook, but that process was discontinued by Zoom in early 2020.
No recording of mediation proceedings should be permitted without full disclosure, awareness and informed consent of all participants. Any authorized recording should only be recorded to and stored on the host’s computer, not in the Zoom cloud, to preserve privacy.
Loss of Personal Contact
Although there is no personal contact as noted above, ODR participants do get to see and hear one another. Where there is animosity, removing personal contact may be a benefit. “I will miss nonverbal cues” seems to be a theoretical objection rather than one grounded in experience. In fact, because a speaker can look through their camera lens directly into the eyes of every participant simultaneously, Zoom actually allows an opportunity not available in a face-to-face mediation. The best advice I can give to a reluctant participant is to try Zoom for the scheduling conference and observe how much information they can obtain through the microphone and camera before writing off ODR.
3rd Party Participation
While it is possible for non-parties to eavesdrop and to coach parties, this is equally possible when a participant in the physical world is left alone in a private room or uses an electronic device to record or broadcast proceedings surreptitiously.
Yes, it is far easier for third parties to snoop in ODR, but neutrals can ask guests to agree to not do it and to include their agreement as a term in the agreement to mediate or preliminary order for arbitration; discuss appropriate sanctions for violations; require guests to scan the room with their cameras to confirm the absence of third parties, etc. But especially in mediation, I would prefer to have the new spouse directly involved in the negotiations to ward off Monday morning quarterbacking and undermining a proposed settlement agreement.
Parties’ Perspective of ODR
Zoom mediation participants require very little instruction. I provide a one-page handout with basic instructions on installing the software along with my invitation to participate in the actual mediation. I offer a free one-on-one practice session to all attendees. I conduct pre-mediation my scheduling conferences and preliminary hearings on arbitrations via Zoom to introduce attorneys to the platform.
- For the full Zoom experience, participants need:
- To download and installation (www.Zoom.us) ahead of mediation
- A fast, stable, secure, non-public internet connection with a
fully-charged computer or telephone or other device plugged into
a power source - A quiet, well-lit space with participant facing a light source
- Minimal distractions and interruptions, i.e., no pets,
small children, telephone calls, electronic interference
I warn about privacy and confidentiality; no recording allowed; no eavesdropping or interruptions; no undisclosed third-party participation, only those invited by the mediator. I explain the waiting room and private room features which are used to protect their privacy.
ODR from the Mediator’s Perspective
Zoom videoconferencing requires a strong, secure internet connection and a backup plan in case the technology fails. Use Zoom to conduct the preliminary hearing and scheduling conference. Employ all the security features discussed above and like the cab driver said when asked, “How do I get to Carnegie Hall?” Practice, practice, practice! Practice with colleagues, family, friends, and clients to help them overcome any techno phobia they may be experiencing. Ask your neutral for a one-on-one test drive.
Try the ODR experience with your next mediation or arbitration.
You can do this!
Bio – Robert Wright has a wealth of experience in ADR as a seasoned and respected litigator, arbitrator, and mediator for more than 30 years. Recognized as a statewide leader of mediation, Bob has participated as either a neutral or a representative in ADR proceedings involving more than a thousand individuals and businesses in both business and personal disputes.
He customizes his mediation style to meet participants’ needs, helping them settle their differences quickly and economically, in a wide variety of disputes from business, bankruptcy, and employment matters, to family matters and even community public policy issues. In addition to his wealth of practical experience, he inspires and motivates participants through his uncompromising ethics, insightfulness, empathy, compassion, and genuine love of mediation.
A former partner with Miller, Canfield, Paddock & Stone for more than 20 years, Bob represented the interests of businesses and individuals in all aspects of commercial litigation from simple business-to-business contract disputes to complex Chapter 11 bankruptcy matters. In 2000, he discovered his true calling: assisting individuals and businesses to resolve their disputes more efficiently, cost-effectively and with greater satisfaction by serving as a neutral mediator. To pursue his passion, he resigned as a partner with Miller Canfield, became Senior Counsel with the firm and formed The Peace Talks, PLC, devoted solely to serving as an ADR neutral.
Bob gives back by volunteering with various national, state, and local ADR organizations and serving in many leadership positions. He has chaired the ADR Sections of both the State Bar of Michigan and the Grand Rapids Bar Association and the ABA Dispute Resolution Section’s Practice Management Committee. He recently drafted proposed new local ADR rules to bring mediation to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Michigan. He serves as an unpaid volunteer mediator for the Dispute Resolution Center of West Michigan (also past board president) and as an advisor on the Mediation Advisory Board for ICLE.
A sought-after speaker on ADR topics throughout the country, Bob also trains mediators in ADR courses, including ICLE’s award-winning 40-hour basic mediation training program, and various advanced trainings for mediators, lawyers, and judges offered by state and local courts, bar associations, and dispute resolution centers, including the Michigan Supreme Court.
Along with his law degree from Wayne State, Bob holds an MA in psychology from the University of Santa Monica (2001) and has completed over 350 hours of intensive mediation trainings including: the Harvard Mediation Workshop (40 hours); Michigan General Civil Mediation (40 hours); Michigan Domestic Relations Mediation with Domestic Violence Screening Protocols (48 hours); Public Policy Mediation (30 hours); Transformative Mediation (40 hours); NVC Mediation (60 hours); and countless hours of Advanced ADR trainings.
Bob has long held the distinguished “AV” rating by Martindale-Hubbell and is perennially recognized with Best Lawyer™ and Michigan Super Lawyer™ designations, testaments to the wide respect and confidence he has earned from his peers for his knowledgeable, ethical and professional services as a neutral.
In addition to PREMi, Bob is listed on the rosters of the American Arbitration Association (employment & commercial panels); MWI (bankruptcy & commercial panels); U.S. Postal Service REDRESS program (employment discrimination panel); DeMars & Associates (CAP-RV arbitration program); and numerous state and federal court lists of approved neutrals.
Our Professionals
* Member Emeritus
Case Studies
india online pharmacy: best india pharmacy – reputable indian pharmacies
http://indianpharmgrx.shop/# legitimate online pharmacies india
http://canadianpharmgrx.com/# best canadian pharmacy
best online pharmacy india [url=http://indianpharmgrx.shop/#]Generic Medicine India to USA[/url] top 10 online pharmacy in india
https://indianpharmgrx.com/# india pharmacy
how much robaxin can i take at once
https://mexicanpharmgrx.com/# mexican mail order pharmacies
mexico pharmacy: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – buying from online mexican pharmacy
medication canadian pharmacy: List of Canadian pharmacies – canada rx pharmacy world
purchase azithromycin sale – order ciplox without prescription ciprofloxacin 500 mg cost
best online pharmacy india [url=https://indianpharmgrx.shop/#]Generic Medicine India to USA[/url] indian pharmacy
http://mexicanpharmgrx.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
best canadian online pharmacy reviews: online canadian pharmacy – canada drug pharmacy
http://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
online pharmacy canada [url=https://canadianpharmgrx.com/#]canadapharmacyonline[/url] real canadian pharmacy
http://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/# best online pharmacies in mexico
oral cleocin 150mg – buy cefpodoxime 100mg pills cheap chloramphenicol pills
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=https://mexicanpharmgrx.com/#]buying from online mexican pharmacy[/url] mexico pharmacy
canadian pharmacy price checker: Cheapest drug prices Canada – canada drugs online review
dexilant vs protonix
canadian pharmacies online: Cheapest drug prices Canada – best mail order pharmacy canada
http://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/# canadian pharmacy online
Хотите, чтобы [url=http://tpk-mss.ru]квартира в новостройке[/url] стала вашим уютным жилищем?
Мы знаем, как сделать это качественно и без лишних хлопот! В нашей статье мы поделимся с вами секретами [url=http://tpk-mss.ru]ремонта квартиры под ключ[/url]. Узнайте, как создать интерьер своей мечты, сделав [url=http://tpk-mss.ru]перепланировку квартиры[/url] с минимумом затрат и максимумом комфорта. Пусть ваша квартира отражает ваш вкус и стиль!
Специальная скидка для вас – 10%!
repaglinide cost in india
http://mexicanpharmgrx.com/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
pharmacy website india [url=http://indianpharmgrx.com/#]Healthcare and medicines from India[/url] india pharmacy mail order
http://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/# safe canadian pharmacy
my canadian pharmacy: canadian pharmacies compare – canadian pharmacy review
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican pharmacy – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
Хотите [url=http://antech18.ru]купить квартиру в новостройке[/url], но не знаете, с чего начать?
Мы подготовили для вас рекомендации по [url=http://antech18.ru]покупке жилья от застройщика[/url] и многим другим важным моментам.
Узнайте, как правильно подготовиться к покупке [url=http://antech18.ru]новостройки на стадии котлована[/url] и избежать неприятных сюрпризов в будущем. Мы поможем вам принять верное решение и сэкономить время и деньги.
2euMmu1fxQiHdn3aFcDOGXg0ruR
https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/# cheap canadian pharmacy
mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/#]mexican drugstore online[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
reputable canadian online pharmacy: International Pharmacy delivery – cheap canadian pharmacy online
cipro 500mg best prices [url=http://ciprofloxacin.guru/#]п»їcipro generic[/url] ciprofloxacin generic price
Добро пожаловать на наш портал, где вы сможете найти множество полезных статей на такие темы, как [url=http://gorodkrovli.ru]прием квартиры в новостройке[/url] и [url=http://gorodkrovli.ru]проверка недвижимости[/url].
Узнайте больше о том, как [url=http://gorodkrovli.ru]купить новостройку без отделки[/url]. Мы поможем вам стать уверенным покупателем и избежать различных проблем в будущем!
diflucan online buy: diflucan tablets australia – diflucan otc where to buy
http://ciprofloxacin.guru/# where can i buy cipro online
tamoxifen 20 mg [url=https://nolvadex.icu/#]should i take tamoxifen[/url] arimidex vs tamoxifen bodybuilding
п»їcytotec pills online: buy cytotec over the counter – Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
can i buy diflucan over the counter: diflucan discount coupon – medicine diflucan price
cytotec pills online: cytotec online – cytotec pills buy online
diflucan buy nz [url=https://diflucan.icu/#]diflucan 110 mg[/url] diflucan.com
doxycycline: doxycycline 200 mg – doxycycline vibramycin
На нашем ресурсе вы найдете множество полезных статей на такие темы, как: [url=http://renta8.ru ]отделка новой квартиры[/url] и [url=http://renta8.ru ]ремонт в новостройке с материалами[/url].
Узнайте, как выбрать дизайн интерьера при [url=http://renta8.ru ]чистовой отделке квартир[/url]!
Мы подскажем вам оптимальные решения и поделимся секретами красивого дизайна и отделки.
Также мы предлагаем вам личную скидку на консультацию – 20%!
diflucan 1 otc: diflucan for sale – diflucan tabs
doxycycline 100mg tablets: cheap doxycycline online – buy doxycycline online
tamoxifen men [url=https://nolvadex.icu/#]who should take tamoxifen[/url] tamoxifen adverse effects
doxycycline 200 mg: how to buy doxycycline online – where to get doxycycline
purchase cipro: antibiotics cipro – where can i buy cipro online
stromectol for human – stromectol order online cefaclor 500mg oral
http://diflucan.icu/# diflucan tablets buy online
tamoxifen medication [url=http://nolvadex.icu/#]tamoxifen estrogen[/url] nolvadex pills
buy cytotec over the counter: buy cytotec online – cytotec pills online
tamoxifen medication: tamoxifen alternatives premenopausal – does tamoxifen cause weight loss
buy cytotec online fast delivery: buy misoprostol over the counter – buy cytotec over the counter
tamoxifen effectiveness [url=https://nolvadex.icu/#]tamoxifen alternatives[/url] tamoxifen hair loss
nolvadex gynecomastia: nolvadex 20mg – tamoxifen 20 mg tablet
cytotec online [url=https://misoprostol.top/#]Abortion pills online[/url] buy cytotec online fast delivery
order doxycycline online: generic for doxycycline – buy doxycycline online
doxycycline online: vibramycin 100 mg – purchase doxycycline online
Misoprostol 200 mg buy online: buy cytotec online fast delivery – buy cytotec online
http://doxycyclinest.pro/# buy doxycycline online 270 tabs
buy cytotec over the counter: buy cytotec in usa – Cytotec 200mcg price
buy cytotec online fast delivery [url=https://misoprostol.top/#]cytotec buy online usa[/url] buy cytotec over the counter
ciprofloxacin mail online: buy cipro online canada – buy cipro online
Misoprostol 200 mg buy online: п»їcytotec pills online – Abortion pills online
order cytotec online: Cytotec 200mcg price – Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
buy albuterol 2mg generic – order theo-24 Cr 400 mg online cheap theo-24 Cr canada
diflucan 110 mg: diflucan.com – diflucan 150 mg otc
http://misoprostol.top/# Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
buy misoprostol over the counter: Misoprostol 200 mg buy online – п»їcytotec pills online
Cytotec 200mcg price [url=https://misoprostol.top/#]purchase cytotec[/url] purchase cytotec
cytotec pills buy online: buy cytotec over the counter – buy cytotec pills online cheap
ciprofloxacin order online: ciprofloxacin generic price – ciprofloxacin
order zithromax over the counter [url=http://azithromycina.pro/#]zithromax online pharmacy canada[/url] zithromax online paypal
prednisone without a prescription: prednisone buy online nz – prednisone 7.5 mg
ivermectin 4 tablets price: minocycline 100 mg over the counter – what does minocycline treat
what is the drug remeron used for?
prednisone cost us [url=https://prednisonea.store/#]prednisone 50 mg coupon[/url] prednisone without a prescription
http://azithromycina.pro/# zithromax price canada
where buy clomid pills: can you buy generic clomid without a prescription – can i order generic clomid without a prescription
zithromax antibiotic without prescription: how to buy zithromax online – zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online
stromectol 3mg tablets [url=http://stromectola.top/#]cost of ivermectin[/url] buy ivermectin cream for humans
how to buy zithromax online: zithromax purchase online – zithromax 500 mg lowest price drugstore online
zocor synthroid
http://clomida.pro/# how can i get clomid prices
zithromax prescription online: buy zithromax online cheap – zithromax 600 mg tablets
prednisone uk price: how much is prednisone 10mg – prednisone 5mg price
zithromax 1000 mg online [url=http://azithromycina.pro/#]zithromax purchase online[/url] can i buy zithromax over the counter
prednisone 5 mg: buy prednisone online australia – prednisone 10 mg tablet cost
https://amoxicillina.top/# over the counter amoxicillin canada
buy medrol 8mg online – how to buy singulair order astelin 10 ml for sale
zithromax order online uk: can you buy zithromax over the counter in canada – where can i buy zithromax capsules
https://prednisonea.store/# prednisone 20mg prices
zithromax z-pak: azithromycin zithromax – where can i buy zithromax capsules
zithromax generic price [url=http://azithromycina.pro/#]order zithromax over the counter[/url] zithromax for sale cheap
http://amoxicillina.top/# amoxicillin without rx
generic ivermectin for humans: buy stromectol canada – price of ivermectin tablets
zithromax coupon: zithromax cost canada – zithromax antibiotic without prescription
spironolactone dehydration
http://prednisonea.store/# 15 mg prednisone daily
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# online pharmacy prescription
cheap ed pills [url=https://edpill.top/#]cheapest ed medication[/url] best online ed meds
cheap prescription drugs online: buying drugs without prescription – buying prescription medications online
can you buy prescription drugs in canada: no prescription drugs – no prescription online pharmacy
http://edpill.top/# erection pills online
http://edpill.top/# where to buy ed pills
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# buying prescription drugs from canada
cheapest prescription pharmacy [url=http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/#]rxpharmacycoupons[/url] offshore pharmacy no prescription
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# buying prescription drugs in canada
get ed prescription online: erection pills online – erectile dysfunction drugs online
clarinex price – order aristocort online cheap purchase ventolin generic
non prescription online pharmacy india [url=http://medicationnoprescription.pro/#]buying prescription medicine online[/url] canadian prescription prices
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# no prescription required pharmacy
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# prescription free canadian pharmacy
rxpharmacycoupons: overseas pharmacy no prescription – canadian pharmacy world coupon
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# online canadian pharmacy coupon
cheap ed meds online [url=https://edpill.top/#]buy erectile dysfunction pills[/url] erectile dysfunction pills online
metformin vs sitagliptin
mail order prescription drugs from canada: online pharmacy no prescription needed – rxpharmacycoupons
http://medicationnoprescription.pro/# online prescription canada
cheap pharmacy no prescription: online pharmacy no prescription needed – canadian pharmacy world coupon
http://medicationnoprescription.pro/# buying prescription medicine online
http://edpill.top/# buying erectile dysfunction pills online
allegra synthroid
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# buy prescription drugs without a prescription
erectile dysfunction online [url=https://edpill.top/#]low cost ed meds online[/url] buy ed medication online
rx pharmacy no prescription: canadian online pharmacy no prescription – no prescription needed pharmacy
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# best canadian pharmacy no prescription
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam [url=http://casinvietnam.com/#]casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam[/url] choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam [url=http://casinvietnam.shop/#]game c? b?c online uy tin[/url] casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
tamsulosin hexal nebenwirkungen
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: dánh bài tr?c tuy?n – choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i
https://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
http://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
buy glyburide paypal – pioglitazone medication forxiga brand
can you take venlafaxine while pregnant
casino online uy tín: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
https://casinvietnam.shop/# web c? b?c online uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín – dánh bài tr?c tuy?n
https://casinvietnam.shop/# web c? b?c online uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – dánh bài tr?c tuy?n
web c? b?c online uy tín: web c? b?c online uy tín – web c? b?c online uy tín
https://casinvietnam.com/# web c? b?c online uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n: casino tr?c tuy?n – casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín
http://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
glucophage 1000mg for sale – losartan 25mg canada precose 50mg sale
voltaren cream reviews
does tizanidine show up in a drug test
casino tr?c tuy?n [url=http://casinvietnam.shop/#]casino tr?c tuy?n[/url] danh bai tr?c tuy?n
web c? b?c online uy tín: dánh bài tr?c tuy?n – web c? b?c online uy tín
http://casinvietnam.com/# web c? b?c online uy tin
[url=http://tadalafi.online/]cialis prescription price australia[/url]
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam [url=http://casinvietnam.com/#]game c? b?c online uy tin[/url] casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
casino tr?c tuy?n: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i
https://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
web c? b?c online uy tín: casino online uy tín – casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín
danh bai tr?c tuy?n [url=http://casinvietnam.com/#]choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i[/url] game c? b?c online uy tin
game c? b?c online uy tín: game c? b?c online uy tín – casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i [url=https://casinvietnam.shop/#]casino online uy tin[/url] casino online uy tin
zyprexa intramuscular
game c? b?c online uy tín: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – dánh bài tr?c tuy?n
https://casinvietnam.com/# web c? b?c online uy tin
choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i [url=https://casinvietnam.shop/#]casino online uy tin[/url] casino tr?c tuy?n
http://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam – dánh bài tr?c tuy?n
choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i [url=https://casinvietnam.com/#]casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam[/url] web c? b?c online uy tin
http://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i: choi casino tr?c tuy?n trên di?n tho?i – casino tr?c tuy?n uy tín
casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin [url=http://casinvietnam.shop/#]web c? b?c online uy tin[/url] game c? b?c online uy tin
https://casinvietnam.shop/# game c? b?c online uy tin
casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam: game c? b?c online uy tín – casino tr?c tuy?n
http://casinvietnam.shop/# danh bai tr?c tuy?n
casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin [url=http://casinvietnam.com/#]game c? b?c online uy tin[/url] danh bai tr?c tuy?n
repaglinide usa – buy generic prandin empagliflozin 10mg usa
canadian pharmacy ltd [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Prescription Drugs from Canada[/url] canadian pharmacies online
https://mexicoph24.life/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
buying from online mexican pharmacy [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]cheapest mexico drugs[/url] buying from online mexican pharmacy
how does wellbutrin xl work for smoking
http://indiaph24.store/# cheapest online pharmacy india
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian drugs online
canadian pharmacy meds [url=http://canadaph24.pro/#]Prescription Drugs from Canada[/url] legitimate canadian pharmacy online
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
legal canadian pharmacy online [url=http://canadaph24.pro/#]Large Selection of Medications from Canada[/url] online canadian pharmacy reviews
https://indiaph24.store/# reputable indian pharmacies
http://indiaph24.store/# cheapest online pharmacy india
online pharmacy india [url=https://indiaph24.store/#]Generic Medicine India to USA[/url] pharmacy website india
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexico pharmacy
best india pharmacy [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]Cheapest online pharmacy[/url] Online medicine order
https://indiaph24.store/# india online pharmacy
http://indiaph24.store/# top 10 online pharmacy in india
canadian pharmacy com [url=http://canadaph24.pro/#]adderall canadian pharmacy[/url] adderall canadian pharmacy
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
real canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]canadian pharmacies[/url] safe canadian pharmacy
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian drugstore online
https://indiaph24.store/# legitimate online pharmacies india
canadian pharmacy prices [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Prescription Drugs from Canada[/url] pet meds without vet prescription canada
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican rx online
mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]Mexican Pharmacy Online[/url] mexican rx online
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
zofran zydis wafers during pregnancy
http://canadaph24.pro/# best online canadian pharmacy
mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]cheapest mexico drugs[/url] reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian drug
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian drugs
Online medicine home delivery [url=https://indiaph24.store/#]Generic Medicine India to USA[/url] online shopping pharmacy india
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
top online pharmacy india [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]Generic Medicine India to USA[/url] reputable indian online pharmacy
zyprexa uses
http://indiaph24.store/# best online pharmacy india
www canadianonlinepharmacy [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Certified Canadian Pharmacies[/url] canada pharmacy world
http://canadaph24.pro/# online canadian pharmacy reviews
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
canada pharmacy reviews [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Prescription Drugs from Canada[/url] canadian pharmacy 24
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
buying prescription drugs in mexico online [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican drugstore online
http://mexicoph24.life/# best online pharmacies in mexico
http://indiaph24.store/# mail order pharmacy india
top 10 pharmacies in india [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]indian pharmacy[/url] Online medicine home delivery
order generic semaglutide – buy desmopressin for sale DDAVP order
http://canadaph24.pro/# cheap canadian pharmacy online
zetia reviews
http://indiaph24.store/# online shopping pharmacy india
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
best canadian online pharmacy [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Licensed Canadian Pharmacy[/url] canada rx pharmacy
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
india pharmacy [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]buy medicines from India[/url] reputable indian online pharmacy
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy store
http://indiaph24.store/# Online medicine home delivery
top online pharmacy india [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]indian pharmacy fast delivery[/url] reputable indian pharmacies
order terbinafine 250mg generic – cheap lamisil grifulvin v price
https://mexicoph24.life/# best online pharmacies in mexico
india pharmacy mail order [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]indian pharmacy fast delivery[/url] pharmacy website india
indian pharmacy paypal [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]buy medicines from India[/url] best online pharmacy india
http://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy mail order
canadian pharmacy 24h com [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Certified Canadian Pharmacies[/url] canadian family pharmacy
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian world pharmacy
https://indiaph24.store/# indian pharmacies safe
reputable canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Certified Canadian Pharmacies[/url] canadian compounding pharmacy
https://mexicoph24.life/# best mexican online pharmacies
buying prescription drugs in mexico online [url=https://mexicoph24.life/#]cheapest mexico drugs[/url] mexican drugstore online
https://canadaph24.pro/# legitimate canadian pharmacies
https://canadaph24.pro/# canadian discount pharmacy
reputable mexican pharmacies online [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]cheapest mexico drugs[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy
http://indiaph24.store/# top online pharmacy india
https://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy
best canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]canadian compounding pharmacy[/url] northwest pharmacy canada
http://indiaph24.store/# legitimate online pharmacies india
medication from mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicoph24.life/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://indiaph24.store/# buy medicines online in india
indian pharmacies safe [url=https://indiaph24.store/#]indian pharmacy[/url] indian pharmacy
http://mexicoph24.life/# best online pharmacies in mexico
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
india pharmacy mail order [url=https://indiaph24.store/#]indian pharmacy[/url] buy prescription drugs from india
https://indiaph24.store/# indian pharmacy online
https://indiaph24.store/# Online medicine order
canada pharmacy world [url=http://canadaph24.pro/#]Licensed Canadian Pharmacy[/url] canadian drug stores
http://mexicoph24.life/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
canadian pharmacy king [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]buy canadian drugs[/url] canada pharmacy world
http://indiaph24.store/# reputable indian pharmacies
http://indiaph24.store/# buy prescription drugs from india
buying prescription drugs in mexico [url=https://mexicoph24.life/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
https://mexicoph24.life/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy
https://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy mail order
http://mexicoph24.life/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Licensed Canadian Pharmacy[/url] rate canadian pharmacies
http://mexicoph24.life/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
top 10 online pharmacy in india [url=https://indiaph24.store/#]buy medicines from India[/url] reputable indian online pharmacy
https://indiaph24.store/# buy medicines online in india
canadian 24 hour pharmacy [url=https://canadaph24.pro/#]Large Selection of Medications from Canada[/url] canadian drugs pharmacy
order generic nizoral 200mg – order lotrisone without prescription order sporanox 100mg for sale
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy meds review
https://canadaph24.pro/# pharmacy canadian superstore
northwest canadian pharmacy [url=http://canadaph24.pro/#]canadian pharmacies[/url] canadian drug prices
https://canadaph24.pro/# best canadian online pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=http://mexicoph24.life/#]cheapest mexico drugs[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://indiaph24.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
pharmacy com canada [url=http://canadaph24.pro/#]Licensed Canadian Pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy in canada
https://indiaph24.store/# reputable indian pharmacies
order famciclovir 250mg pill – zovirax generic buy valaciclovir 500mg generic
https://indiaph24.store/# Online medicine order
indianpharmacy com [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]Online medicine home delivery[/url] top 10 pharmacies in india
https://mexicoph24.life/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian pharmacy meds
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=https://mexicoph24.life/#]mexico pharmacy[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico
reputable indian online pharmacy https://indiaph24.store/# best online pharmacy india
reputable indian online pharmacy
reputable indian online pharmacy http://indiaph24.store/# india online pharmacy
buy medicines online in india
https://indiaph24.store/# mail order pharmacy india