Richard L. Hurford
In last month’s ADR Spotlight, my PREMI colleague, Laura Athens, authored an incredibly insightful and important article on the psychology of conflict and how litigants process information when in conflict. As this discussion goes to the heart of the mediation process, a continuation of this discussion is in order.
Mediators and professional negotiators have long known:
- Conflict clearly impacts certain human behavior (often in very predictable ways).
- The importance of recognizing all aspects and permutations of human behavior in conflict
- A condition precedent to successful negotiations is developing strategies to address unproductive human behaviors and resistance to change typically generated by conflict
The strategies and practices neutrals pursue to meet the psychological behaviors of people in conflict are central to an understanding of the effectiveness of mediation and various negotiation techniques utilized by mediators in helping parties resolve their dispute. As noted by Ms. Athens, while many users of mediation have a tendency to dismiss the “feel good” or “soft side” of mediation as impediments to the goal of resolving disputes as quickly as possible, and become impatient with the processes employed by mediators, “hard” neuroscience,” and cognitive behavioral studies of people in conflict underscore the dangers in attempting of just“getting to the bottom line” too quickly.
Psychological studies underscore that any number of cognitive reactions can be used in both proactive and reactive ways. Negotiations and mediations require, inter alia, the mediator and the attorney to evaluate the reasons a client might be resistant to or apprehensive with the change a settlement may cause. They need to be sensitive in recognizing that a client’s reluctance to resolve a dispute may be driven by one (or a combination) of five distinct motives:
1) fear of change;
2) status quo bias;
3) risk aversion;
4) high uncertainty avoidance;
5) situational distrust.
It is essential to have the emotional intelligence to distinguish the differences as each requires unique approaches and negotiation strategies.
The research indicates the human brain has various centers that control and drive different human activities and thinking: the triune brain (the first brain the amygdala; the second brain the mid brain; and the third brain the frontal cortex).
During mediation and the negotiation processes, all of the dynamics of communication, perception, cognition, fear, flight or fight, biases, etc., are grounded
on processes in the brain and how the brain deals with conflict and human cognition. Individuals under pressure tend to adopt an adversarial or binary approach to
problem- solving. The reptilian brain, (the amygdala or first brain in the graphic) with its adrenalin-driven protective flight, fight, or freeze response, that evolved to protect our ancestors from physical threats, is still active and thriving in our brains today and often reacts in predictable ways.
Indeed, virtually all personal injury lawyers are familiar with the term “reptilian theory” as it has been the basis for the formulation of litigation tactics that allegedly have particular appeal to the fears of typical jurors. While one might question the allegedly
irrational positions that parties might take during conflict resolution, it is often more helpful to evaluate whether the opposing party is just being human in predictable ways (rather than irrational) and develop targeted negotiation strategies to minimize the typical psychological impediments to reaching a resolution.
A well-documented predictable attribute of the brain in conflict (related to our fight or flight instincts governed by the amygdala or first brain), which we all share to one degree or another, is “confirmation bias.” Confirmation bias is the natural tendency to search for data that confirms our beliefs, as opposed to looking for data that might challenge those beliefs. Indeed, confirmation bias is one of the brain’s natural waysto catalog and remember (obviously in a selective manner) all the information that floods us every day. As observed by Warren Buffet, “What the human being is best at doing is interpreting all new information so that their prior conclusions remain intact.
”For example, how many times have attorneys and clients during a mediation
accused their negotiating partners of suffering from“selective memory?” or “refusing to acknowledge” the significance of facts contrary to their legal and factual positions. Rather than believing that one is engaging in dishonest behavior, it most likely reflects the well-known psychological phenomenon that all of us engage in confirmation bias.
When the brain is in conflict confirmation bias is not easily managed. In fact, vociferously arguing the facts and law with someone inclined to extreme confirmation bias may generate the “backfire effect”– people will cling even more strongly to their positions when challenged with opposing evidence. After all, who wants to admit they are wrong? One reason mediators use “reality testing,” often in private caucus, is to evaluate the extent of confirmation bias. When it exists, rather than continuing the discussion of who is “right” or “wrong, ”mediators will use techniques to move on to
the far more productive exercise of cortical brainstorming for possible solutions to the conflict.
Other examples of confirmation bias involve the discussions mediators often conduct when asked to convey an offer (particularly if it is the first economic offer or response). Think about all the times you have participated in a mediation as an attorney when your client’s first reaction to an offer was to claim “the other side is not being serious,” or is otherwise “not engaging in good faith negotiations.” Similarly, how many times have you heard from the mediator that the first reaction by your negotiating partner
to your first offer was the accusation you are not really interested in settling or are negotiating in bad faith? No better example of confirmation bias is needed – the
first offer or demand only confirms the bias the opposing party is not prepared to negotiate in good faith. One of the many strategic issues the counselor and mediator must contemplate is how to best formulate and rationally justify their first offer or response to minimize the adverse and most predictable impact of confirmation bias. When the mediator inquires, “what is the message you desire to send with this offer?
Or “how do you think the other side will react to this offer?” consider whether this is a potential red flag that your negotiation position is not particularly strategic and will only give rise to counter-productive confirmation bias that will fail to productively advance the settlement objectives of the client.
“Cognitive dissonance” is at play in virtually all mediations. Studies indicate that humans prize harmony between their actions and beliefs. Accordingly, when acting contrary to a strong belief, alarm bells go off in the brain, and we feel discomfort or “dissonance.” To eliminate this tension, an individual can either abandon the belief (which may be difficult if the belief is firmly held) or change the behavior that causes the dissonance. This means that parties who have already invested substantial time and money litigating with an adversary may find it psychologically difficult to accept the weaknesses of their own case, or the strength of their opponent’s position. To avoid the potential cognitive dissonance they may simply resist any resolution of the dispute.
Litigants will also tend to demonize the other side (particularly true in personal injury, employment, partnership dissolutions, family, and probate law) will often question why they would ever want to come to an agreement with a bunch of liars, crooks, or some other negative characterization. Cognitive dissonance is at play when even reasonable offers for a resolution are quickly rejected.
In this context mediators are also very familiar with the concept of “reactive devaluation.” That is, the value of a proposal to resolve a dispute is devalued when presented by the negotiating “adversary” far more than when a neutral party advances the proposal. How many times during a mediation or negotiation have we experienced (either stated or unstated) the perception that “if the other side is offering X then must be good for them; and if it is good for them, X must be bad for me.” While X might be a most reasonable proposal, reactive devaluation may render that proposal unacceptable. One approach a mediator may take to counteract reactive devaluation may involve an exploration of a party’s “checklist” or objectives (other than just monetary) to be accomplished during the course of the mediation. If a party identifies to the mediator several key interests and objectives for the negotiation, both large and small, and the mediator explores with that party proposals that might help achieve those objectives, then a proposal from the other side along the lines desired by that party will not so readily be devalued. It was simply the mediator doing the job of securing the terms that one party wanted. That is why mediators will often deal with the less complicated non-economic issues first and reach agreement on those before mov- ing on to the more complicated matters. The goals are to minimize reactive devaluation and develop positive negotiation momentum. While it may be “all about the money,” there are sound psychological reasons to deal with “small issues” first before moving on to the more problematic aspects of the conflict.
Behavioral science has also taught mediators the importance of “reframing.” Nobel laureate Danile Kahneman and his partner Amos Tversy published a paper in 1979 regarding “loss aversion,” finding that people are more sensitive to loss than to gains. Studies of risk aversion are important for mediators and negotiators to know because “if loss aversion suppresses the ability to imagine reward, it may have additional effects on one’s ability to think creatively about how to meet their desire for reward.” Thus reframing the perceived detriments of the change in the status quo to focus on the potential benefits of such change fosters what all mediators and their attorneys search for cortical creative problem solving. Thus if business partners are in a dispute and “hate working or dealing with each other,” one reframing exercise might be to ask: “as I understand your position, one of your objectives may be to minimize or eliminate your dealings with your partner; how do you think that might best be accomplished.” Instead of focusing upon the dislike of the business partner, mediator reframing is intended to stimulate the search for solutions through cortical thinking and creativity.
Two other tools sometimes used by mediators during both joint sessions and private caucuses relate to emotions – allowing parties to “vent,” and “looping” (acknowledging the emotions underlying a party’s concerns which is not to be confused with agreeing with the reasons for the emotions). Neuroscience tells us that when someone is angry, it triggers a biological fight or flight response that makes rational choice difficult. As emotions are filters for our perception, the brain’s amygdala interprets our emotions to switch our decision-making process between the reptilian instinctual thinking and higher-level cortical thinking. Thus the mediator develops strategies to assist parties in making the transition to higher- level thinking. During the joint session, and depending upon the circumstances, the mediator may, at some point, summarize the respective positions of the parties, capturing the important points, including the emotional aspects, to ensure the party has been heard. In some instances, the mediator may even be more aggressive than counsel or the clients in summarizing their respective positions (but accurately capture the unstated accusations), which augments the venting of the parties and is also a form of looping. Depending on the circumstances, the technique can help establish that: the mediator “gets it” (i.e., vali- dating the emotion as opposed to agreeing with the reasons for the emotion); there are two sides to every story; prolonged arguing about the correctness of each side’s story is probably futile; and, a greater appreciation for the other side’s position as each client will tend to listen to the other side of the story more intently and calmly when presented by an even-handed neutral.
While most mediators and their counsel understand that “venting” is important to the mediation process and for the parties to have an uninterrupted time to retell events in detail, neuroscience tells us that one’s neurons may actually relive the painful experience associated with the conflict. That is why many mediators will permit an exhaustion of the venting process at the outset of the mediation and discourage retelling of the events that led to the dispute. Instead, the parties will be encouraged to focus and think cortically about the future and how to shape the future to arrive at a more positive outcome. There is a sound, evidence-based reason (i.e., based upon behavioral studies) that mediators will often state something to the effect:
“It is not really my job to determine who was right or wrong but to help you focus on creative solutions to the dispute,” or “we all agreed the goal of the mediation is not an attempt to determine who might be right or wrong – the objective is to determine if a resolution can be reached. Do I have your permission at this time to focus on the possible solutions that will meet your needs? My recollection of the needs you wanted to obtain were (list the needs previously discussed). Is there anything I missed? What are your thoughts on how we can go about achieving those goals for you?”
Mediators will use such strategies and others to harness the emotions at mediation to shift one’s thinking from the amygdala to the cortex of the brain.
The characteristics of brain function may also explain why mediation is sometimes feared or resisted, and why there may be a great reluctance to engage in joint sessions. During joint sessions, the mediator’s ground rules will typically call on the participants to reflectively listen to the opposing party, strive to understand and potentially empathize with the opposing party, and potentially legitimatize the other party’s experiences. While joint sessions, when appropriately managed and orchestrated, can effectively minimize the impact of confirmation bias and other impediments to resolution identified in Ms. Athens’ article and the above, in the hands of some counsel and parties joint sessions can be counter-productive and actually exacerbate the fight-or-flight amygdala paradigm thinking that most parties, including attorneys, bring to the litigation. When evaluating the wisdom of a joint session, consider how best to minimize the adverse consequences of the unproductive biases that are a detriment to the negotiation process. While effective joint sessions can be most helpful, and there are a number of strategies the mediator might suggest for an effective joint session (that cannot readily be duplicated in a caucus only context), when not well done joint sessions can be most inimical to the negotiation process.
Understanding the brain’s impact on conflict resolution does not require a degree in psychology. It does require an appreciation of predictable consequences of the impact of conflict on human behavior, patience and perseverance. While there can be a tendency to become impatient with the processes mediators may employ and believe insufficient progress is being made during the mediation, the mediation process needs to mature over time, and it is not unusual for there to be multiple bargaining rounds in virtually all mediations. While few studies evaluate the number of offers and counteroffers made during the “typical” mediation (a “round” consists of one offer and one response to that offer), the following findings were reported from a review of over 400 mediated employment cases that resulted in a settlement:
Rounds of No. of
bargaining Cases
1 15
2 31
3 56
4 79
5 66
6 47
7 or more 64
The average number of negotiating rounds in settled cases in this study was 4.6. In another study, the average number of bargaining rounds in settled cases was 4.86 in mediations involving court-ordered medical malpractice claims. As each mediation is unique, the average number of rounds is instructive only to the extent it underscores the significant range of bargaining rounds that may be required for the successful resolution of any dispute.
It does take time and potentially numerous rounds of bargaining to address the various impediments to a resolution that may be driven more by predictable human behavior rather the terms of a resolution that will ultimately be mutually satisfactory and beneficial to all parties to the dispute. It does take far more time and effort to come to a resolution than it does to come to an impasse. You hired the mediator for process expertise; exercise the patience and persistence to achieve the benefits of that expertise.
————————
Richard L. Hurford is the president of Richard Hurford Dispute Resolution Services PC and a principal in ADRoit Dispute Resolution Services and Strongbridge Negotiation Strategists PC. With over 40 years of litigation experience and service as a neutral in ADR processes and an inductee into the Michigan Lawyer’s Hall of Fame. He is the past chair of the ADR Section of the State Bar of Michigan; the Macomb ADR Committee, the Oakland County ADR Committee, the ADR Section of the Federal Bar Association for the Eastern District of Michigan, and the ADR Committee of the Engineering Society of Detroit. He has received distinguished service awards from the State Bar of Michigan, the Macomb County Bar Association and the Engineering Society of Detroit. A perennial Martindale AV preeminent rated and Best™ lawyer he is a frequent lecturer and author on ADR and a contributor to the Supreme Court Administrative Office’s publication the Michigan Judges Guide to ADR Practice and Procedure and a coauthor of two prior editions of the nationally acclaimed “The ABCs of ADR and So Much More: A Practical Desk Guide for Judges and Attorneys.” The most recent edition of the ABCs is slated for publication in the next two months.
Our Professionals
* Member Emeritus
Case Studies
remeron vs prozac
buy zithromax 500mg – where can i buy ofloxacin order ciplox for sale
buy cleocin without a prescription – cleocin for sale cheap chloromycetin sale
protonix liquid
ivermectin buy online – eryc generic cefaclor usa
ventolin for sale – order fexofenadine theophylline pills
repaglinide vidal
robaxin and pregnancy
acantha sitagliptin
spironolactone while breastfeeding
medrol 16 mg over counter – buy montelukast 10mg pill order azelastine 10 ml generic
synthroid potency
buy desloratadine 5mg online cheap – buy flixotide online cheap ventolin inhalator order
is voltaren safe to take if you have afiband afib
venlafaxine adhd
buy generic glyburide – pill dapagliflozin 10 mg forxiga cheap
tamsulosin nursing considerations
tizanidine for opiate withdrawal
metformin 1000mg cost – glycomet 500mg tablet precose 25mg cheap
buy repaglinide 2mg pills – buy repaglinide without a prescription jardiance cheap
zetia reviews
wellbutrin sr generic cost
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – mexican pharmacy
zyprexa lawsuit
zofran odt peak
top 10 pharmacies in india https://indiaph24.store/# top online pharmacy india
Online medicine home delivery
lamisil 250mg over the counter – buy generic fulvicin online griseofulvin without prescription
order semaglutide 14 mg generic – glucovance ca buy DDAVP generic
zyprexa shot
kytril and zofran used together
purchase ketoconazole generic – cheap butenafine sporanox 100 mg for sale
buy famvir generic – buy zovirax 800mg without prescription valcivir order online
https://indiaph24.store/# Online medicine order
http://canadaph24.pro/# canadian mail order pharmacy
reputable indian pharmacies Cheapest online pharmacy indian pharmacies safe
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: Online Pharmacies in Mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://canadaph24.pro/# canada drug pharmacy
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
comprar
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Compra
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Vozačka dozvola B
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Kupiti
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Med
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Rijbewijs
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Kupiti 2
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Шофьорска книжка 2
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Шофьорска книжка
Thanks for this awesome post. I really enjoyed reading it and I hope to read more of your content. It’s inspirational.
Conducao
buy prinivil: lisinopril 5 mg tabs – zestoretic canada
https://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen citrate pct
cytotec buy online usa buy cytotec online fast delivery order cytotec online
buy cytotec online fast delivery: cytotec online – buy cytotec over the counter
п»їcytotec pills online buy cytotec in usa Abortion pills online
order digoxin 250mg for sale – oral irbesartan 150mg buy furosemide generic diuretic
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# buy cipro online without prescription
zestril 5mg price in india lisinopril prescription coupon lisinopril 5mg tablets
buy cytotec pills: cytotec abortion pill – cytotec pills online
http://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen and depression
https://lisinopril.network/# benicar lisinopril
antibiotics cipro buy ciprofloxacin over the counter buy cipro online
cipro online no prescription in the usa: cipro pharmacy – ciprofloxacin over the counter
http://finasteride.store/# cost propecia without prescription
lisinopril 40 buy lisinopril 5 mg lisinopril 2.5 tablet
tamoxifen for sale: tamoxifen cancer – tamoxifen men
http://lisinopril.network/# can i order lisinopril over the counter
https://ciprofloxacin.tech/# buy generic ciprofloxacin
antibiotics cipro buy cipro online ciprofloxacin order online
lisinopril tablets: zestril 2.5 mg – buying lisinopril in mexico
propecia tablets propecia rx propecia cheap
https://cytotec.club/# cytotec pills buy online
lisinopril 3760: generic lisinopril 10 mg – zestoretic generic
buy ciprofloxacin over the counter buy cipro online canada cipro online no prescription in the usa
https://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 5 mg brand name in india
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# ciprofloxacin generic price
buy cytotec buy cytotec over the counter buy misoprostol over the counter
Misoprostol 200 mg buy online: Misoprostol 200 mg buy online – cytotec buy online usa
lopressor 50mg drug – lopressor 100mg generic order nifedipine for sale
buy microzide generic – buy felodipine 5mg online cheap bisoprolol 5mg uk
https://ciprofloxacin.tech/# purchase cipro
ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price ciprofloxacin mail online antibiotics cipro
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.
buy cytotec over the counter: buy cytotec online fast delivery – buy cytotec over the counter
https://cytotec.club/# cytotec abortion pill
lisinopril 18 mg prinivil online benicar lisinopril
https://finasteride.store/# get propecia price
lisinopril 10 mg pill: lisinopril 10 mg brand name in india – cost of lisinopril in mexico
levitra pill online
order generic levitra online
https://ciprofloxacin.tech/# cipro online no prescription in the usa
generic tamoxifen tamoxifen men arimidex vs tamoxifen bodybuilding
buy ciprofloxacin: antibiotics cipro – cipro pharmacy
cost of generic propecia without rx order propecia tablets buying cheap propecia no prescription
https://cytotec.club/# purchase cytotec
Buy Cialis online: cialist.pro – buy cialis pill
viagra without prescription viagras.online Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada
https://cialist.pro/# Buy Cialis online
Buy Vardenafil online: Levitra generic price – Cheap Levitra online
https://viagras.online/# Cheapest Sildenafil online
tadalafil benefits
Levitra tablet price: Levitra generic price – Levitra 10 mg best price
Buy Tadalafil 10mg Generic Tadalafil 20mg price Cialis 20mg price in USA
https://kamagra.win/# super kamagra
cialis wears off
buy nitroglycerin medication – purchase combipres online cheap buy valsartan without a prescription
Kamagra 100mg: Kamagra 100mg price – buy Kamagra
super kamagra buy kamagra online buy kamagra online usa
http://cenforce.pro/# Purchase Cenforce Online
https://viagras.online/# Cheap generic Viagra online
buy Kamagra: kamagra pills – buy Kamagra
Levitra online USA fast buy Levitra over the counter Levitra 10 mg buy online
Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription: Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription – Cialis 20mg price in USA
http://cenforce.pro/# buy cenforce
Cialis without a doctor prescription buy cialis online Generic Tadalafil 20mg price
Buy Cenforce 100mg Online: Cenforce 100mg tablets for sale – buy cenforce
http://cialist.pro/# Cialis without a doctor prescription
http://kamagra.win/# Kamagra tablets
Kamagra 100mg buy kamagra online sildenafil oral jelly 100mg kamagra
https://kamagra.win/# cheap kamagra
Cialis without a doctor prescription: buy cialis overseas – Buy Cialis online
cheapest cenforce: Cenforce 150 mg online – order cenforce
canada prescription: order prescription drugs online without doctor – canadian rx prescription drugstore
uk pharmacy no prescription online pharmacy canadian pharmacy no prescription
https://pharmnoprescription.icu/# canada pharmacies online prescriptions
canadian pharmacy no prescription: canada pharmacy coupon – pharmacy no prescription required
zocor also – zocor fumble atorvastatin remind
buying prescription drugs from canada online: canadian pharmacy non prescription – best online pharmacy that does not require a prescription in india
canadian pharmacies online canadian drugs online canadian mail order pharmacy
https://pharmworld.store/# canadian pharmacy no prescription
buy prescription drugs from india: world pharmacy india – reputable indian pharmacies
mexico pharmacy: mexican pharmaceuticals online – medication from mexico pharmacy
purple pharmacy mexico price list mexico pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
indian pharmacies safe: world pharmacy india – world pharmacy india
http://pharmcanada.shop/# pharmacy rx world canada
http://pharmmexico.online/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
recommended canadian pharmacies pharmacy canadian superstore safe reliable canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy without prescriptions: online pharmacy that does not require a prescription – buy meds online without prescription
http://pharmcanada.shop/# canada drug pharmacy
order rosuvastatin 10mg pills – caduet buy explosion caduet buy moral
online shopping pharmacy india: buy prescription drugs from india – mail order pharmacy india
pharmacy website india Online medicine order indian pharmacy online
http://pharmcanada.shop/# pharmacy com canada
mexican mail order pharmacies: best online pharmacies in mexico – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy coupon: pharm world store – canadian online pharmacy no prescription
canadian pharmacy world coupon canadian pharmacy no prescription needed canada pharmacy not requiring prescription
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://pharmindia.online/# indian pharmacies safe
how much is amoxicillin prescription: where to buy amoxicillin 500mg – where to buy amoxicillin pharmacy
how much is amoxicillin amoxicillin without a doctors prescription where can you get amoxicillin
medicine prednisone 5mg: buy prednisone 40 mg – prednisone daily use
https://zithromaxa.store/# where can i get zithromax over the counter
how to make levitra more effective
buying levitra online
how to get amoxicillin over the counter amoxicillin 825 mg amoxicillin 500mg cost
prednisone buy online nz: prednisone 21 pack – where can i get prednisone over the counter
doxycycline 500mg: generic doxycycline – 100mg doxycycline
prednisone 10 mg: prednisone brand name – buy prednisone online uk
amoxicillin 500mg prescription: cost of amoxicillin – amoxicillin 500mg without prescription
order doxycycline online: doxycycline 100mg dogs – buy doxycycline without prescription
http://prednisoned.online/# ordering prednisone
price of doxycycline buy doxycycline hyclate 100mg without a rx doxylin
drug neurontin 20 mg: how much is neurontin pills – gabapentin 600 mg
cialis one a day with dapoxetine canada
zithromax 500 tablet: zithromax without prescription – zithromax 500mg
https://amoxila.pro/# amoxicillin 500mg price canada
buy viagra professional whole – viagra gold online eastward levitra oral jelly importance
gabapentin: buy neurontin uk – neurontin 600 mg tablet
how much is zithromax 250 mg zithromax for sale 500 mg zithromax online paypal
cialis wiki
200 mg doxycycline: order doxycycline online – doxycycline monohydrate
https://gabapentinneurontin.pro/# neurontin cost in canada
zithromax z-pak price without insurance zithromax cost zithromax purchase online
buy amoxicillin 500mg capsules uk: amoxicillin from canada – can i buy amoxicillin over the counter in australia
http://amoxila.pro/# amoxicillin without rx
cost of brand name neurontin neurontin 200 mg tablets neurontin 600 mg price
doxycycline hyclate 100 mg cap: doxycycline 50mg – buy doxycycline online without prescription
zithromax online usa no prescription: zithromax 250 mg pill – buy zithromax online fast shipping
zithromax 500mg over the counter: where can i buy zithromax in canada – zithromax cost canada
doxycycline hyclate 100 mg cap doxycycline 100mg tablets doxycycline 100 mg
http://zithromaxa.store/# zithromax online
priligy plant – suhagra waiter cialis with dapoxetine butter
doxycycline 100 mg: doxycycline prices – doxycycline 100 mg
can you buy amoxicillin over the counter canada azithromycin amoxicillin how to get amoxicillin over the counter
http://doxycyclinea.online/# doxycycline
prednisone online australia: prednisone 20 mg pill – prednisone steroids
where to get doxycycline: doxycycline 500mg – doxycycline 100mg online
amoxicillin order online no prescription can you buy amoxicillin uk buy amoxicillin online with paypal
https://gabapentinneurontin.pro/# generic neurontin cost
cellcept online pharmacy
australian pharmacy viagra
prednisone over the counter cost: where to buy prednisone in canada – prednisone 10 mg tablet
buy cheap prednisone: prednisone cream rx – buy prednisone 10 mg
odering doxycycline doxycycline 100mg dogs buy doxycycline for dogs
http://zithromaxa.store/# zithromax generic cost
buy amoxicillin online without prescription: amoxil generic – amoxicillin canada price
gabapentin generic neurontin price south africa gabapentin online
https://zithromaxa.store/# zithromax 500mg price
doxycycline order online: doxycycline 150 mg – buy doxycycline monohydrate
can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in canada: buying amoxicillin online – buy amoxicillin 500mg usa
cenforce fumble – kamagra pills shine brand viagra online arrangement
neurontin 100 mg capsule neurontin without prescription buy neurontin 300 mg
sildenafil 50 mg price at walgreens
http://amoxila.pro/# buy amoxicillin online no prescription
zithromax 250 mg australia: zithromax 250 mg pill – order zithromax over the counter
neurontin brand name 800mg: neurontin tablets 100mg – neurontin prices
sildenafil 50mg
zithromax cost australia buy zithromax canada purchase zithromax online
http://zithromaxa.store/# zithromax azithromycin
prednisone buy no prescription: prednisone 20mg cheap – prednisone 12 tablets price
prednisone 20 mg tablets coupon: prednisone 5mg price – can i buy prednisone from canada without a script
prednisone brand name prednisone for cheap by prednisone w not prescription
https://prednisoned.online/# buy prednisone 20mg without a prescription best price
brand cialis soft – apcalis ground penisole design
order prednisone online canada: where to buy prednisone without prescription – can you buy prednisone over the counter in mexico
where can i buy zithromax capsules: zithromax 250 mg pill – how to get zithromax online
amoxicillin medicine over the counter order amoxicillin uk where can you buy amoxicillin over the counter
https://doxycyclinea.online/# order doxycycline 100mg without prescription
can you buy zithromax over the counter in mexico: zithromax 250mg – buy zithromax online with mastercard
zithromax 500: zithromax online pharmacy canada – buy zithromax online fast shipping
prednisone 50 mg prices prednisone buy without prescription average cost of generic prednisone
buying prescription drugs in mexico: best mexican online pharmacies – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican pharmaceuticals online: buying from online mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmaceuticals online
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: medication from mexico pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican rx online mexico drug stores pharmacies mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
buying prescription drugs in mexico: medication from mexico pharmacy – reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# mexican rx online
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican rx online
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexican rx online
https://mexicanpharmacy1st.online/# mexico pharmacy
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
purple pharmacy mexico price list medicine in mexico pharmacies mexican pharmaceuticals online
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – reputable mexican pharmacies online
https://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# mexican drugstore online
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican mail order pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican pharmacy: mexican mail order pharmacies – medicine in mexico pharmacies
cialis soft tabs pills attend – cialis soft tabs fireplace viagra oral jelly solitary
mexican drugstore online: buying prescription drugs in mexico – mexican drugstore online
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
brand cialis midst – apcalis snatch penisole adult
mexican mail order pharmacies mexican pharmacy mexican mail order pharmacies
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
medication from mexico pharmacy: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – medication from mexico pharmacy
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: medication from mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican pharmacy
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: best mexican online pharmacies – best mexican online pharmacies
https://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
mexico pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies buying from online mexican pharmacy
buying from online mexican pharmacy: best mexican online pharmacies – mexican pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmacy1st.online/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican pharmacy mexican rx online pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexican pharmacy: purple pharmacy mexico price list – mexico pharmacy
buying from online mexican pharmacy: medication from mexico pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexican drugstore online
http://mexicanpharmacy1st.com/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
medicine in mexico pharmacies buying from online mexican pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
https://gabapentin.club/# neurontin cost
people’s pharmacy nexium
indian pharmacies safe
buy cytotec pills online cheap: order cytotec online – п»їcytotec pills online
buy cytotec online Abortion pills online buy cytotec online fast delivery
http://gabapentin.club/# neurontin cost generic
buy lisinopril online india: lisinopril 15 mg tablets – buy lisinopril in mexico
https://clomiphene.shop/# order generic clomid
can i get generic clomid without prescription where can i get cheap clomid no prescription how to get clomid without insurance
buying generic propecia without dr prescription cost cheap propecia price buying generic propecia for sale
lisinopril 20mg prices: lisinopril 5 mg india price – zestril 5 mg prices
https://propeciaf.online/# get generic propecia without a prescription
order generic propecia price: order propecia without insurance – order propecia without insurance
buy cytotec in usa: Abortion pills online – order cytotec online
neurontin 800 mg price neurontin 100mg cost neurontin 300mg caps
https://cytotec.xyz/# purchase cytotec
cialis soft tabs print – cialis super active pills brisk1 viagra oral jelly online hurt
https://cytotec.xyz/# cytotec online
sildenafil roman
where can i get generic clomid pills: can you get clomid – cost of clomid without a prescription
cost of cheap propecia without rx propecia tablet cost generic propecia for sale
https://propeciaf.online/# generic propecia pill
cost of clomid without insurance where buy clomid without insurance get cheap clomid without rx
neurontin 300 mg capsule: neurontin oral – neurontin 600 mg pill
http://gabapentin.club/# neurontin pills
Abortion pills online buy cytotec online Cytotec 200mcg price
price for 5 mg lisinopril: buy lisinopril online india – zestril 5mg
http://lisinopril.club/# lisinopril 12.5 mg tablets
canada where to buy neurontin: neurontin brand name 800mg – where to buy neurontin
cytotec pills buy online cytotec buy online usa Abortion pills online
buy lisinopril online india: lisinopril 12.5 tablet – lisinopril brand
get generic propecia pill order propecia pills get propecia without insurance
buying generic propecia without dr prescription: cost generic propecia without rx – order cheap propecia without dr prescription
https://36and6health.com/# canadian pharmacy coupon code
https://cheapestandfast.shop/# no prescription needed
canadian pharmacy tampa: cheapest canada – canadian pharmacy sarasota
http://36and6health.com/# canadian prescription pharmacy
india online pharmacy best online pharmacy india best online pharmacy india
https://cheapestindia.com/# mail order pharmacy india
https://cheapestandfast.shop/# best online pharmacy without prescriptions
http://cheapestmexico.com/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
world pharmacy india: Online medicine order – best india pharmacy
buying online prescription drugs cheapest & fast pharmacy pharmacy no prescription
https://cheapestmexico.com/# medication from mexico pharmacy
https://cheapestmexico.shop/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
https://cheapestcanada.shop/# canadian pharmacy
cenforce week – brand viagra pills farewell
dapoxetine hundred – levitra with dapoxetine myrtle cialis with dapoxetine trouble
http://cheapestcanada.com/# reputable canadian pharmacy
buy drugs online without a prescription: cheapest and fast – buying drugs online no prescription
http://cheapestmexico.com/# medication from mexico pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no prescription cheapest & fast pharmacy no prescription online pharmacies
https://cheapestcanada.com/# best canadian pharmacy to buy from
farmacias direct: farmacia online barata y fiable – farmacias online seguras
http://eufarmaciaonline.com/# farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a
europa apotheke gГјnstigste online apotheke gГјnstigste online apotheke
beste online-apotheke ohne rezept: europa apotheke – online apotheke
pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale: pharmacie en ligne livraison europe – pharmacie en ligne pas cher
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: pharmacie en ligne france – pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale
acne medication swim – acne medication far acne medication weigh
farmacia online 24 horas farmacia online barcelona farmacia online barcelona
Pharmacie sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne fiable – pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
inhalers for asthma quarter – inhalers for asthma papa asthma treatment hate
farmacias online baratas: farmacias online seguras – farmacia online envÃo gratis
comprar vardenafil
lowest price vardenafil
https://eufarmaciaonline.com/# farmacia online 24 horas
ohne rezept apotheke online apotheke rezept ohne rezept apotheke
п»їfarmacia online espaГ±a: п»їfarmacia online espaГ±a – farmacias direct
farmacia online barcelona: farmacia online españa envÃo internacional – farmacias direct
online apotheke rezept online apotheke preisvergleich online apotheke gГјnstig
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: migliori farmacie online 2024 – farmacie online autorizzate elenco
farmacia online envÃo gratis: farmacias online baratas – farmacias online seguras
farmacia en casa online descuento: farmacias direct – farmacia en casa online descuento
farmacia online envГo gratis: farmacia online barata – farmacia online barata
apotheke online gГјnstige online apotheke medikamente rezeptfrei
farmacia online madrid: farmacias direct – farmacias online seguras
online apotheke versandkostenfrei: online apotheke günstig – europa apotheke
cheap tadalafil 10mg
http://euapothekeohnerezept.com/# medikament ohne rezept notfall
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale vente de mГ©dicament en ligne Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
Pharmacie Internationale en ligne: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
find tadalafil
Achat médicament en ligne fiable: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique
farmacias online baratas: п»їfarmacia online espaГ±a – farmacia online envГo gratis
apotheke online medikamente rezeptfrei beste online-apotheke ohne rezept
uti medication help – uti medication into uti medication hall
ohne rezept apotheke: online apotheke gГјnstig – online apotheke
farmacia online 24 horas: farmacia online barata y fiable – farmacia online barcelona
prostatitis treatment unpleasant – prostatitis treatment leaf prostatitis pills further
farmacia online barata y fiable farmacias online seguras п»їfarmacia online espaГ±a
farmacia online senza ricetta: farmacie online autorizzate elenco – farmacie online affidabili
online apotheke preisvergleich: online apotheke – medikamente rezeptfrei
https://eufarmaciaonline.shop/# farmacia online envГo gratis
farmacia en casa online descuento: farmacias online seguras en españa – farmacias online seguras
eu apotheke ohne rezept eu apotheke ohne rezept online apotheke rezept
online apotheke gГјnstig: online apotheke rezept – internet apotheke
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: acquistare farmaci senza ricetta – farmacia online
medikamente rezeptfrei: günstige online apotheke – medikament ohne rezept notfall
internet apotheke: gГјnstigste online apotheke – online apotheke gГјnstig
https://levitraenligne.com/# acheter médicament en ligne sans ordonnance
п»їpharmacie en ligne france levitra generique pharmacie en ligne
acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance: Acheter Cialis – Pharmacie sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne: cialis prix – pharmacie en ligne pas cher
pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique: kamagra livraison 24h – pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
Viagra sans ordonnance 24h Amazon: Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance – Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france
vente de mГ©dicament en ligne: kamagra en ligne – pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: Levitra sans ordonnance 24h – pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance
valacyclovir pills flare – valacyclovir pills eater valtrex online impatient
loratadine medication gratitude – claritin pills too claritin quill
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne fiable: cialis prix – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance kamagra en ligne Pharmacie sans ordonnance
Viagra pas cher inde: Viagra pas cher paris – SildГ©nafil 100 mg prix en pharmacie en France
Sildenafil teva 100 mg sans ordonnance: Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – SildГ©nafil Teva 100 mg acheter
https://cenligne.com/# trouver un médicament en pharmacie
Hello.
This post was created with XRumer 23 StrongAI.
Good luck 🙂
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: kamagra en ligne – pharmacie en ligne
Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique: viagra sans ordonnance – Quand une femme prend du Viagra homme
Hello!
This post was created with XRumer 23 StrongAI.
Good luck 🙂
п»їpharmacie en ligne france: pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance – trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale: acheter kamagra site fiable – п»їpharmacie en ligne france
pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne fiable – pharmacie en ligne france fiable
pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: kamagra en ligne – pharmacie en ligne fiable
vente de mГ©dicament en ligne: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – п»їpharmacie en ligne france
priligy breathless – priligy warrior dapoxetine response
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: levitra generique – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
SildГ©nafil 100 mg prix en pharmacie en France: viagra sans ordonnance – Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france
claritin pills feather – claritin grave claritin pills endless
Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h: Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – Viagra homme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance
vente de mГ©dicament en ligne: levitra generique – Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: cialis prix – Pharmacie sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: levitra en ligne – pharmacie en ligne france fiable
Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france: Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – Acheter viagra en ligne livraison 24h
pharmacie en ligne: cialis sans ordonnance – Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
Pharmacie sans ordonnance: levitra generique prix en pharmacie – pharmacie en ligne pas cher
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – pharmacie en ligne fiable
ascorbic acid clear – ascorbic acid broom ascorbic acid bye
pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: Levitra sans ordonnance 24h – Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – pharmacie en ligne fiable
promethazine scene – promethazine whether promethazine bush
trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie: pharmacie en ligne livraison europe – trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie
pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: Levitra 20mg prix en pharmacie – Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
tadalafil classification
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: kamagra livraison 24h – pharmacie en ligne fiable
pharmacie en ligne: Pharmacies en ligne certifiees – pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale: cialis generique – vente de mГ©dicament en ligne
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: levitra generique – pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
pharmacie en ligne fiable: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – Pharmacie sans ordonnance
clarithromycin pills observe – cytotec exact cytotec though
pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: kamagra en ligne – pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: levitra generique prix en pharmacie – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique: Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance – Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique
trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie: Levitra pharmacie en ligne – п»їpharmacie en ligne france
pharmacie en ligne fiable: cialis generique – pharmacie en ligne
florinef pills second – protonix whirl prevacid pills exclaim
http://levitraenligne.com/# acheter médicament en ligne sans ordonnance
Viagra gГ©nГ©rique sans ordonnance en pharmacie: Viagra generique en pharmacie – Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france
acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance: levitra en ligne – pharmacie en ligne
Le gГ©nГ©rique de Viagra: Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – Viagra vente libre allemagne
pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: Acheter Cialis – pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale
pharmacie en ligne france pas cher: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – п»їpharmacie en ligne france
Viagra homme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance: Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance – Viagra sans ordonnance livraison 48h
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: pharmacie en ligne – trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne livraison europe – pharmacie en ligne pas cher
pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es: pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique
pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: kamagra en ligne – п»їpharmacie en ligne france
Viagra sans ordonnance livraison 24h: viagra en ligne – Viagra sans ordonnance pharmacie France
rabeprazole 10mg drug – buy metoclopramide pill where to buy domperidone without a prescription
how to buy bisacodyl – dulcolax 5 mg cheap order liv52 pills
bactrim 480mg for sale – buy keppra online cheap tobrex 5mg over the counter
forxiga pills – order sinequan 25mg buy precose generic
buy fulvicin pills – brand gemfibrozil 300mg lopid pill
ed drug vardenafil levitra
vardenafil vs sildenafil vs tadalafil
sildenafil vardenafil tadalafil
dimenhydrinate 50mg for sale – risedronate medication buy risedronate 35 mg without prescription
vasotec online buy – order generic latanoprost buy latanoprost generic
bbc pharmacy valium
mexican pharmacy online xanax
online pharmacy buy oxycodone
etodolac online buy – cilostazol 100mg without prescription brand pletal 100mg
feldene 20 mg price – buy feldene 20mg without prescription order rivastigmine generic
belize pharmacy hydrocodone
rx city pharmacy auburn ny
compare rx prices
Hyzaar
https://autolux-azerbaijan.com/# Pin up 306 casino
Pin Up Kazino ?Onlayn: pin-up360 – Pin Up Kazino ?Onlayn
https://autolux-azerbaijan.com/# Pin-up Giris
pin-up360: Pin up 306 casino – Pin Up
pin-up kazino: Pin Up Azerbaycan ?Onlayn Kazino – Pin Up
https://autolux-azerbaijan.com/# Pin Up Azerbaycan ?Onlayn Kazino
Pin Up Azerbaycan: Pin Up Azerbaycan – Pin-Up Casino
https://autolux-azerbaijan.com/# Pin up 306 casino
pin-up kazino: pin-up 141 casino – pin-up 141 casino
https://autolux-azerbaijan.com/# ?Onlayn Kazino
Pin up 306 casino: Pin-up Giris – Pin Up
buy nootropil cheap – sinemet 10mg pill buy sinemet paypal
hydrea uk – buy generic hydrea for sale methocarbamol 500mg usa
divalproex 500mg canada – amiodarone 200mg over the counter topiramate 200mg sale
buy norpace pill – lamictal medication buy thorazine generic
https://jisuzm.tv/home.php?mod=space&uid=4002682
http://www.zian100pi.com/discuz/home.php?mod=space&uid=842279
http://z.8g.cm/home.php?mod=space&uid=1546944
https://fileforum.com/profile/hopeport49/
buy generic cyclophosphamide – generic vastarel order vastarel pill
order aldactone online cheap – order dosulepin without prescription revia 50 mg ca
https://maps.google.com.sa/url?q=https://handlelook31.werite.net/shattered-no-more-the-ultimate-guide-to-auto-glass-replacement
https://emplois.fhpmco.fr/author/saltcolony20/
https://www.pcb.its.dot.gov/PageRedirect.aspx?redirectedurl=https://zenwriting.net/beachturkey16/clear-as-glass-the-ultimate-guide-to-auto-glass-replacement
buy flexeril 15mg for sale – enalapril 10mg drug buy generic enalapril for sale
generic ondansetron 4mg – eldepryl pills requip pills
order generic ascorbic acid 500mg – isordil order online cheap generic compro
how to buy durex gel – purchase durex condoms online purchase latanoprost without prescription
where can i buy rogaine – how to buy finpecia brand proscar 1mg
leflunomide pill – alfacip usa buy cartidin generic
calan 120mg sale – buy tenoretic online tenoretic canada
atenolol usa – brand sotalol 40mg buy cheap generic coreg
cheap atorvastatin tablets – order generic vasotec 10mg buy bystolic medication
cheap generic gasex – where to buy diabecon without a prescription cheap diabecon tablets
generic lasuna – order lasuna pill buy himcolin pill
cheap norfloxacin online – flutamide where to buy buy confido sale