Joe Basta
“It’s not fair!” How many times have mediators and negotiators heard that refrain? Whether from the mouth of the negotiator across the table or the politician seeking higher taxes, everyone wants their “fair share.” But what is ‘”fairness” anyway?
Is there a more subjective, elusive, or slippery word anywhere in the dictionary? Like other perceptions that affect negotiation, fairness is in the mind of the beholder. Yet the concept is not without objective parameters, and periodic review of fairness guidelines might be helpful to ADR providers and consumers before they resort to emotional arguments about “what’s fair.”
“An outcome that appears to be fair may be more important than winning or losing,” observe ADR authors Jay Folberg and Dwight Golann in “Lawyer Negotiation.” Our perception of fairness consists of two components, distributional fairness and procedural fairness. The former is the quantitative outcome – what you get in the negotiation; the latter is the process used to get there – how you were treated. Both provide the foundation for analyzing the fairness of any negotiation.
The most recent and illuminating illustration of the interplay of distributional and procedural fairness comes courtesy of the Baltimore Ravens NFL football team. As Andrew Beaton reported in the Wall Street Journal, the Ravens propose that the NFL abandon the conventional coin toss for starting overtime. Under current rules, when a game goes into overtime, the referee tosses a coin; the winner gets to decide whether they want the ball or choose to defend. The problem is the winner most often chooses the ball because that statistically determines who wins the game. So it turns out the revered coin toss – the gold standard of who goes first, a 50/50 chance – is not so fair after all in this context.
The Ravens propose a “spot and choose” method to eliminate this luck factor. After a coin toss, the winner picks starting field position; then the other team decides if wants to play offense or defense from that spot. Consider this a football variant of how two friends divide a piece of cake: one cuts, the other chooses. Nobel Prize winning economist, Richard Thaler, from the University of Chicago, endorses the Ravens’ proposal as simple, fair, and fun.
You can see why procedural fairness is so important in football: the distributional outcome is win/lose, all or nothing. The procedural process had better be solid because there is no compromise in the result of the distribution. The same logic applies to resorting to trial to determine conflict outcome where negotiation breaks down. The parties accept the legitimacy of a verdict – even one they don’t like because they respect the process that produced it.
Respect for procedural fairness reflects why mediation is a trusted and popular method of dispute resolution. The parties may design their own “spot and choose” method of facilitated negotiation. And even if they choose not to actively design the process, their opportunity to participate in facilitated negotiation with an experienced mediator provides the parties with control and an opportunity to be heard that they would not otherwise have in a trial. Even if the outcome is not exactly as they would have preferred, they are willing to accept and implement it.
Procedural fairness plays a role even where par ties choose to negotiate directly rather than to mediate. Which negotiating style or procedure produces the best outcome? While opinions certainly differ and choice of style depends on personality and the details of the negotiation, the research appears to favor an interest based approach to negotiation over a competitive or adversarial one. Consider your negotiating style carefully; it may well determine your outcome.
Like procedural fairness, distributive fairness too is highly subjective. Impartial and educated observers will often disagree about the fairness of an outcome. Not all conflicts will have the definitive outcome of an NFL football game. But here too benchmarks are available to guide decision-making.
Folberg and Golann suggest four competing principles or rules for determining distributive fairness: equality, need, equity, and generosity. Equality means everyone in a group should share its benefits equally. The need principle dictates those who need more should get more than those who need less. Generosity says one’s outcome should not exceed that of others. Equity links distribution to relative contribution.
The authors apply these principles to a hypothetical joint venture between two individuals, one the creator and sweat equity implementer of the idea and the other who supplies the capital for the enterprise. How do you divide their outcome? Equality will distribute income equally; need will give the poorer negotiator – here the creator – more income. Generosity will result in want the income of neither exceeding the other.
And equity will require determining whose contribution is most valuable.
These distributive fairness guidelines may be considered and applied in any negotiation or mediation, not just the joint venture hypothetical. Choosing among them will depend upon things like the complexity of the case, the relationship between the parties, your degree of self-interest, and cultural norms – whether your social group values individualism over collective benefit for example.
So, the next time someone shouts “it’s not fair,” remember the Baltimore Ravens. There is more to decision-making than a simple coin toss. Some tried and true rules for procedural and distributional fairness may provide helpful guidance.
————————
Joe Basta heads Basta Resolutions PLLC, an Ann Arbor-based firm specializing in mediation and arbitration of commercial and family disputes. He is a former chair of the Alternative Dispute Resolution Section of the State Bar of Michigan. Basta was a trial lawyer for over 34 years at Dykema, litigating complex commercial matters. He teaches negotiation at the Michigan State University College of Law and is a member of Professional Resolution Experts of Michigan Inc. (https://premiadr.com).
Our Professionals
* Member Emeritus
Case Studies
dydrogesterone 10mg ca dapagliflozin 10 mg uk generic jardiance 25mg
buy etodolac cheap cilostazol online buy cheap pletal 100mg
brand fludrocortisone 100 mcg fludrocortisone 100mcg drug imodium where to buy
buy prasugrel 10mg online where can i buy detrol order tolterodine 2mg pills
pyridostigmine pills cost piroxicam rizatriptan cheap
azithromycin us purchase omnacortil for sale gabapentin 100mg ca
atorvastatin 20mg ca atorvastatin 40mg sale norvasc generic
black jack card game free poker online for money furosemide 40mg price
free online roulette live online blackjack ventolin inhalator for sale
order protonix 40mg for sale cheap pyridium 200 mg buy pyridium pill
online poker free online blackjack best ivermectin 400 mg brands
spins real money online clavulanate tablet order synthroid 75mcg sale
amantadine over the counter purchase tenormin online cheap purchase aczone pill
buy methylprednisolone 8 mg online nifedipine for sale online triamcinolone without prescription
cost vardenafil 10mg cost lanoxin cost zanaflex
purchase dilantin generic oxybutynin 2.5mg canada purchase ditropan pills
coversum drug fexofenadine 120mg cheap allegra 120mg sale
order lioresal order baclofen 25mg without prescription order toradol pill
claritin 10mg over the counter ramipril where to buy purchase dapoxetine for sale
order baclofen 10mg for sale toradol price order toradol 10mg online cheap
order fosamax for sale order colchicine online cheap order furadantin 100 mg without prescription
order inderal 20mg generic ibuprofen 400mg oral order clopidogrel generic
purchase pamelor sale pamelor 25 mg tablet buy anacin without a prescription
amaryl pills etoricoxib canada buy arcoxia 60mg without prescription
buy generic warfarin 2mg how to buy warfarin metoclopramide 20mg cheap
buy xenical 60mg for sale asacol 400mg pills cost diltiazem
pepcid 40mg uk tacrolimus online buy buy tacrolimus medication
nexium 20mg price how to buy topiramate buy topiramate tablets
order azelastine 10 ml buy irbesartan avapro online order
sumatriptan 25mg tablet dutasteride medication buy dutasteride cheap
order zyloprim sale oral zyloprim 100mg order crestor 20mg online cheap
ranitidine medication zantac pill generic celebrex 200mg
buspirone 10mg over the counter where to buy buspin without a prescription cordarone 200mg over the counter
order tamsulosin 0.2mg simvastatin over the counter buy zocor 20mg pills
domperidone 10mg cheap coreg 25mg drug order generic sumycin 500mg
spironolactone 100mg canada buy valtrex online order proscar 1mg without prescription
help write my paper buy term papers online academic writing uk
fluconazole 200mg drug forcan us where can i buy cipro
purchase aurogra generic order aurogra 50mg for sale cheap yasmin
buy flagyl online order cephalexin 250mg pills keflex order
lamictal 50mg canada buy mebendazole 100mg pill buy vermox generic
tamoxifen 20mg cost buy nolvadex without a prescription order budesonide generic
buy tretinoin gel online retin gel without prescription buy generic avanafil for sale
tadacip 10mg cost order diclofenac sale indomethacin 50mg ca
buy trazodone 100mg without prescription buy clindac a online cheap purchase clindamycin gel
lamisil usa lamisil drug best online gambling sites
aspirin 75mg price online casino games real money quick hits free online slots
http://withoutprescription.guru/# legal to buy prescription drugs from canada
top essay writers real money casino slots meaning
buy an assignment write essays for me buy generic suprax online
http://withoutprescription.guru/# buy prescription drugs from india
how to buy doxycycline online: buy doxycycline – doxycycline mono
medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexican rx online – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
http://withoutprescription.guru/# п»їprescription drugs
male erection pills: best pills for ed – cure ed
prescription drugs canada buy online: tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription – buy prescription drugs
buy amoxicillin from canada: how to get amoxicillin – where can i get amoxicillin 500 mg
buy generic calcitriol for sale buy labetalol pills for sale purchase tricor for sale
http://withoutprescription.guru/# prescription drugs
order trimox 250mg generic buy arimidex clarithromycin over the counter
http://kamagra.team/# Kamagra 100mg
Vardenafil buy online Generic Levitra 20mg Levitra 10 mg buy online
http://kamagra.team/# super kamagra
sildenafil 100 how to order sildenafil online sildenafil 100 mg generic price
cost of tadalafil generic: cost of tadalafil in canada – tadalafil mexico price
https://tadalafil.trade/# tadalafil free shipping
how to buy clonidine order tiotropium bromide sale cheap tiotropium bromide 9 mcg
https://edpills.monster/# generic ed drugs
sildenafil 100mg price usa sildenafil 20 mg tablet cheapest sildenafil india
sildenafil tablets india: buy sildenafil us – sildenafil canada cost
https://sildenafil.win/# sildenafil tablets uk
buy kamagra online usa Kamagra tablets Kamagra 100mg price
uroxatral 10mg pills alternatives to allergy medication strongest prescription acid reflux medication
doxycycline 100mg online uk where can i purchase doxycycline doxycycline 75 mg price
amoxicillin 500 mg tablets: buy amoxil – azithromycin amoxicillin
ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online: Ciprofloxacin online prescription – ciprofloxacin
http://azithromycin.bar/# how much is zithromax 250 mg
how to get amoxicillin cheap amoxicillin amoxicillin buy online canada
minocycline 50mg pill minocin tablet buy requip paypal
lisinopril 2.5 mg buy online: Over the counter lisinopril – lisinopril medication
http://amoxicillin.best/# amoxicillin price canada
zestril 20 mg tab buy lisinopril online price for 5 mg lisinopril
cost of generic lisinopril: buy lisinopril – over the counter lisinopril
where can i buy zithromax in canada: can i buy zithromax online – zithromax prescription online
sleeping tablets online shop online prescription weight loss medication weight loss medication online prescription
http://lisinopril.auction/# lisinopril 10mg tablets
doxycycline pharmacy price Buy doxycycline 100mg doxycycline 200 mg pill
zestril 10mg price: buy lisinopril online – price of lisinopril 30 mg
http://azithromycin.bar/# zithromax 500mg over the counter
letrozole 2.5mg over the counter abilify online buy buy aripiprazole no prescription
ciprofloxacin generic price: ciprofloxacin without insurance – buy cipro online canada
amoxicillin without rx amoxil for sale amoxicillin medicine over the counter
zithromax 500 mg for sale: zithromax antibiotic – buy cheap generic zithromax
http://ciprofloxacin.men/# ciprofloxacin
smoking cessation products chart prescription meds to quit smoking pain drugs listed for strengthen
doxycycline minocycline: Doxycycline 100mg buy online – doxycycline gel
zithromax cost australia zithromax antibiotic without prescription zithromax z-pak price without insurance
canadian pharmacy drugs online: accredited canadian pharmacy – canada pharmacy world
best india pharmacy: online pharmacy india – indianpharmacy com
prescription drugs without prescription Online pharmacy USA canadian pharmacy store
http://mexicopharmacy.store/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
buy provera 5mg online buy medroxyprogesterone medication microzide pill
pharmacy in canada: safe online pharmacy – northern pharmacy canada
prescription drugs without doctor: Top mail order pharmacies – best canadian pharmacy cialis
https://ordermedicationonline.pro/# online canadian discount pharmacy
best online herpes medication valacyclovir how long to take insulin pill vs insulin injection
trustworthy canadian pharmacy: certified canada pharmacy online – canadian pharmacy 24h com
approved canadian online pharmacies cheapest online pharmacy prescription drugs online without
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
generic periactin 4mg buy luvox 50mg generic nizoral pills
buy cheap ventolin online: buy Ventolin inhaler – ventolin albuterol inhaler
https://gabapentin.life/# 300 mg neurontin
name of antifungal drugs best foods to lower blood pressure alpha adrenergic antagonists medication list
paxlovid for sale: Paxlovid buy online – п»їpaxlovid
http://gabapentin.life/# neurontin 300 mg
can i buy clomid: Buy Clomid Shipped From Canada – can i buy generic clomid without a prescription
https://paxlovid.club/# paxlovid for sale
paxlovid generic https://paxlovid.club/# Paxlovid buy online
cymbalta 20mg cost buy modafinil 100mg modafinil 100mg without prescription
liquid medicine for stomach ulcers mayo clinic diet for duodenitis cystitis over the counter boots
paxlovid pill: Paxlovid over the counter – buy paxlovid online
https://wellbutrin.rest/# wellbutrin 65mg
can i order clomid: can you buy generic clomid without insurance – where to get generic clomid pills
http://claritin.icu/# ventolin australia
https://gabapentin.life/# neurontin without prescription
no prescription wellbutrin online: Wellbutrin online with insurance – best prices for wellbutrin
buy phenergan generic stromectol 12mg cost ivermectin 12 mg online
order the contraceptive pill online emergency contraception pill near me more ejaculation pills
acquistare farmaci senza ricetta: Dove acquistare Cialis online sicuro – farmacia online
farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: kamagra oral jelly – farmacie online autorizzate elenco
comprare farmaci online all’estero: Farmacie che vendono Cialis senza ricetta – acquisto farmaci con ricetta
farmacia online: Cialis senza ricetta – top farmacia online
http://kamagrait.club/# comprare farmaci online con ricetta
farmacie online sicure Farmacie a milano che vendono cialis senza ricetta migliori farmacie online 2023
acquisto farmaci con ricetta: cialis prezzo – farmacia online senza ricetta
farmacie online autorizzate elenco: Farmacie che vendono Cialis senza ricetta – farmacia online più conveniente
farmacie online sicure: farmacia online – farmacie online sicure
acquistare farmaci senza ricetta: cialis generico consegna 48 ore – acquisto farmaci con ricetta
acquisto farmaci con ricetta: avanafil generico – migliori farmacie online 2023
https://kamagrait.club/# comprare farmaci online con ricetta
farmacia online migliore avanafil prezzo migliori farmacie online 2023
farmacia online migliore: farmacia online più conveniente – acquistare farmaci senza ricetta