Michigan Court of Appeals Reverses Circuit Court Vacatur of Public Sector Labor Arbitration Award

by | May 31, 2024 | The ADR Blog | 400 comments

By Lee Hornberger,
Arbitrator and Mediator

Introduction    

This article reviews Michigan Dep’t of State Police v Michigan State Police Troopers Ass’n, ___ Mich App ___, COA 363241 (December 28, 2023) (Judges Gleicher, Jansen, and Rick), app lv pdg. In Michigan Dep’t of State Police, the Court of Appeals reversed the Circuit Court vacatur of a public sector labor arbitration award.

Précis

Defendant Union appealed the Circuit Court’s order denying the Union’s motion to enforce a labor arbitration award and granting the Employer’s motion to vacate the award. The Court of Appeals reversed the Circuit Court and remanded the case for the entry of an order enforcing the award. The issue was whether the award complied with the terms of collective bargaining agreement (CBA) and whether the Circuit Court substituted its own judgment for that of the arbitrator by vacating the award. The CBA indicated the arbitrator had the authority to reinstate an employee, reduce the length of a suspension, and take any other action necessary to make the employee whole after a wrongful discharge or suspension. The CBA did not prohibit the arbitrator from reducing Grievant’s discipline from discharge to unpaid suspension. The CBA gave the arbitrator the power to determine whether the employee was discharged without just cause. The arbitrator concluded Grievant was discharged without good cause and determined that an unpaid suspension should be imposed. The Court of Appeals held that the Circuit Court erred by vacating the award.   

Factual Outline

Grievant was a Michigan State Police trooper. The events leading to her discharge occurred at a Union event. Grievant was intoxicated and allegedly “wedged her fingers into the anal crevice of a co-worker while he was walking next to his wife.” A surveillance video showed Grievant trying to grab his genitals and  striking a second male coworker in the genitals. Grievant also was recorded attempting to grab the anal crease and genitals of a third male co-employee.

Criminal charges were brought against Grievant. In exchange for the dismissal of the CSC-IV counts, Grievant pleaded no contest to assault and battery. Grievant was sentenced to 30 days in jail. She was released after 21 days.

The Employer discharged Grievant. The arbitrator ruled there was no just cause for the discharge and reinstated Grievant with a suspension.

The Union argued that the arbitrator had sole authority to determine whether there was just cause for discharging Grievant relying on the CBA language providing that “[t]he arbitrator shall have no authority except to pass upon … a claim of suspension, discharge, or demotion without just cause.” Emphasis added.

CBA Article 8, Part A, Section 1, stated:

The Employer will utilize disciplinary action only for just cause toward employees who engage in violations of the Code of Conduct. It is the intention of the Employer to utilize discipline by progression, when appropriate. Emphasis added.

The Award stated:

Essentially, the dispute between the parties is over whether progressive discipline should have been applied rather than termination of employment. …

The key issue is whether under the totality of the circumstances the Employer had just cause for terminating [Grievant]’s employment. Determining just cause requires weighing a number of factors. A very significant factor, which is explicitly included in the parties’ contract, is a consideration of whether progressive discipline is appropriate. …The parties’ contract calls for progressive discipline when appropriate. It is my conclusion that progressive discipline is appropriate in this case.

The Employer asked the Circuit Court to vacate the award. The Union requested that the award by confirmed.  The Circuit Court vacated the award. The Union appealed to the Court of Appeals.

Court of Appeals decision

 The Court of Appeals indicated that a court in an award vacatur action may not substitute its judgment for that of the arbitrator. The court “may only decide whether the arbitrator’s award ‘draws its essence’ from the contract. If the arbitrator in granting the award did not disregard the terms of his employment and the scope of his authority as expressly circumscribed in the contract, judicial review effectively ceases.” Sheriff of Lenawee Co v Police Officers Labor Council, 239 Mich App 111, 118 (1999).

The CBA had provisions discussing the arbitrator’s authority to review discipline and discharge cases. According to the Court of Appeals, “[t]hese provisions directly indicate that the arbitrator has the power to reinstate an employee, reduce the length of a suspension, and take any other action necessary to make an employee whole after wrongful termination or suspension.”

The Employer argued that the CBA limited the arbitrator’s authority to determining whether just cause existed for the discipline, “while leaving the actual method of discipline solely in the [employer]’s hands.”

The Court of Appeals disagreed with the Employer. The Court of Appeals indicated that under CBA Art. 9, Sec. 6:

The arbitrator shall have no authority except to pass upon alleged violations of the expressed written provisions of this Agreement, the unreasonableness or misapplication of a rule or regulation, that a work order was unreasonable and arbitrary or involves discrimination in application, or a claim of suspension, discharge, or demotion without just cause. [Italics in original.]

The Court of Appeals concluded that these portions of the CBA suggest that while the Employer may have authority to suspend or discharge employees, the arbitrator has the power to overturn such decisions if they are made without just cause. According to the Court of Appeals, nothing in the CBA suggests that an arbitrator is only authorized to determine whether just cause existed for the general discipline of an employee, rather than whether just cause existed for discharge. The arbitrator is empowered to determine whether a discharge was without just cause.

 According to the Court of Appeals, the Circuit Court overlooked that the CBA specifically gives the arbitrator the authority to determine whether a discharge was issued without just cause. Logically, if the discharge was without cause, the arbitrator would have the authority to determine, what, if any, discipline should be imposed.

The Employer argued that the award violated public policy. The Circuit Court did not address this issue. The Employer argued that the award was inconsistent with MCL 28.4 which provides that Michigan State Police Officers must be “of good moral character.” The Court of Appeals concluded that this argument lacked merit, indicating “[i]t would be a fairly large leap of logic for this Court to infer that what ultimately amounted to misdemeanant behavior caused by excessive drinking at an after-hours event with coworkers means that the grievant was not of good moral character.” 

Michigan Dep’t of State Police is consistent with the Trilogy

In 1960, the United States Supreme Court issued the Steelworkers Trilogy concerning labor arbitration awards. Steelworkers v Enterprise Wheel Car Corp, 363 US 593 (1960), considered the role of the federal courts in enforcing awards. “The refusal of courts to review the merits of an arbitration award is the proper approach to arbitration under” CBAs because the “federal policy of settling labor disputes by arbitration would be undermined if courts had the final say on the merits of the awards.” Id. at 596.

Michigan Dep’t of State Police is consistent with Michigan case law

Lichon v Morse, 507 Mich 424 (2021), involved an employee manual agreement to arbitrate. Lichon stated,

… in the context of [CBA]s, we [have] held that it was appropriate to apply United States Supreme Court precedent regarding the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) … to contracts entered into under the state’s public employment relations act … . … This is not a rule we have adopted outside of the context of collective bargaining agreements, and we decline to do so now [in an employment arbitration case]. Id. at 467-468.

Beck v Park West Galleries, Inc, 499 Mich 40 (2016), considered whether arbitration clauses in invoices applied to disputes arising from prior purchases when the invoices for prior purchases did not refer to arbitration. Beck held the arbitration clause contained in later invoices cannot be applied to disputes arising from prior sales. Beck recognized the policy favoring arbitration of disputes arising under CBAs but said this does not mean an arbitration agreement between parties outside of the collective bargaining context applies to any dispute arising out of any aspect of their relationship. Beck is an example of the Supreme Court treating an arbitration issue within the collective bargaining process differently from outside the collective bargaining process.

In 36th Dist Ct v Mich Am Fed of State Co and Muni Employees, 493 Mich 879 (2012), the Supreme Court held MCR 3.106 does not preclude reinstatement and back pay where the CBA has a just cause standard for discharge.

Kaleva–Norman–Dickson School District No 6 v Kaleva–Norman–Dickson School Teachers’ Ass’n, 393 Mich 583, 591 (1975), stated,

The policy favoring arbitration of disputes arising under [CBA]s, as enunciated by the United States Supreme Court in the Steelworkers’ Trilogy, is appropriate for contracts entered into under the PERA.

Michigan Association of Police v Pontiac, 177 Mich App 752, 759-760 (1989), stated:

It is accepted that an arbitrator, if not specifically limited by the terms of the collective bargaining agreement, is free to fashion a remedy which considers the relative faults of the parties. … .

Where the CBA is silent as to permissible remedies, an arbitrator does not add to the obligations contractually assumed by the parties by fashioning a remedy which is appropriate under the circumstances. Wayne Co Bd of Comm’rs v National Union of Police Officers, 75 Mich App 375, 381 (1977), lv den 401 Mich 817 (1977).

Michigan Dep’t of State Police consistent with arbitral authority

The Michigan Dep’t of State Police decision is consistent with the proposition that, “[a]bsent a specific provision establishing that violation of a provision [of the CBA] results in discharge, the arbitrator has broad leeway to determine whether the discipline imposed fits the charge of misconduct.” Farrell, “Due Process/Just Cause Issues,” References for Labor Arbitrators (American Arbitration Association, 2005), p. 32. Elkouri & Elkouri, How Arbitration Works (8th ed 2016), pp. 18-46 to 18-49.

Conclusion

            In conclusion, Michigan Dep’t of State Police is consistent with Michigan Supreme Court decisions, the language of the CBA, and general arbitral authority.

______________________

About the Author

Lee Hornberger is a member of the National Academy of Arbitrators.

He is former Chair of Alternative Dispute Resolution Section of State Bar of Michigan, Editor Emeritus of The Michigan Dispute Resolution Journal, former member of SBM Representative Assembly, former President of Grand Traverse-Leelanau-Antrim Bar Association, and former Chair of Traverse City Human Rights Commission.

He is member of Professional Resolution Experts of Michigan (PREMi) and Diplomate Member of The National Academy of Distinguished Neutrals. He is Fellow of American Bar Foundation; and Fellow of Michigan State Bar Foundation.

He has received Distinguished Service Award from SBM ADR Section in recognition of significant contributions to field of dispute resolution and George Bashara Award from ADR Section in recognition of exemplary service. He has received Hero of ADR Awards from ADR Section.

He holds his B.A. and J.D. cum laude from University of Michigan and his LL.M. in Labor Law from Wayne State University.

He can be contacted at leehornberger@leehornberger.com and 231-941-0746. His website is https://www.leehornberger.com/  .

 

Our Professionals

• Laura A. Athens

• Earlene R. Baggett-Hayes

• Joseph C. Basta

• Gene J. Esshaki*

• William D. Gilbride, Jr.

• Lee Hornberger

• Richard L. Hurford

• Michael S. Leib

• Paul F. Monicatti

• Antoinette R. Raheem

• Jerome F. Rock

• Phillip A. Schaedler

• Sheldon J. Stark

• Lisa Taylor

• Martin C. Weisman

• Robert E. L. Wright

  * Member Emeritus

Case Studies

 

 

 

400 Comments

  1. Kadıköy Elektrikçi
    Kadıköy Elektrikçi on June 4, 2024 at 5:41 pm

    Kadıköy elektrikçi olarak kadıköy ilçesine yakın bir konumdayız. Hizmetlerimizi en iyi ekipmanlar ile en uygun fiyatlara yapıyoruz Kadıköy Elektrik Ustası. Kadıköy merkez ve kadıköyün bütün mahallerine profosyonel hizmet kalitesi ile hizmet veriyoruz. https://kansabook.com/ustaelektrikci

  6. Berry Moore
    Berry Moore on June 7, 2024 at 1:10 pm

    Somebody essentially help to make significantly articles I’d state. This is the first time I frequented your web page and up to now? I surprised with the research you made to make this actual post incredible. Fantastic job!

  8. slot gacor
    slot gacor on June 8, 2024 at 6:07 am

    I all the time used to study paragraph in news papers
    but now as I am a user of net therefore from now I am
    using net for articles, thanks to web.

  9. RobertHib
    RobertHib on June 11, 2024 at 12:26 am

    Ищете способ расслабиться и получить незабываемые впечатления? Мы https://t.me/intim_tmn72 предлагаем эксклюзивные встречи с привлекательными и профессиональными компаньонками. Конфиденциальность, комфорт и безопасность гарантированы. Позвольте себе наслаждение и отдых в приятной компании.

  10. keto Cut Ingredients
    keto Cut Ingredients on June 11, 2024 at 1:02 am

    Keto Cut is a popular dietary supplement that is designed to help individuals achieve their weight loss goals through the process of ketosis.

    Also visit my blog :: keto Cut Ingredients

  12. Design and build services
    Design and build services on June 15, 2024 at 3:19 pm

    Hello it’s me, I am also visiting this web site regularly, this
    web site is in fact nice and the viewers are actually sharing good thoughts.

  13. Residential design
    Residential design on June 15, 2024 at 3:22 pm

    Great work! This is the type of information that are supposed
    to be shared across the internet. Disgrace on the search engines for now not positioning this submit upper!
    Come on over and talk over with my web site . Thank you =)

  14. Bathroom renovation
    Bathroom renovation on June 15, 2024 at 4:09 pm

    Hello my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and come with approximately all
    significant infos. I’d like to see extra posts like
    this .

  15. Property renovation
    Property renovation on June 17, 2024 at 3:10 am

    This site was… how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I’ve found something that helped me.
    Thanks a lot!

  16. zaragoza diseño y reformas zaragoza
    zaragoza diseño y reformas zaragoza on June 17, 2024 at 1:48 pm

    It’s hard to come by well-informed people about this subject, however,
    you sound like you know what you’re talking about!

    Thanks

  17. fun88 ถอนเง น นาน ไหม
    fun88 ถอนเง น นาน ไหม on June 17, 2024 at 7:08 pm

    fun88 ถอนเง น นาน ไหม เป็นเว็บไซต์ที่ให้บริการการเข้าสู่ระบบทันใจและปลอดภัยสำหรับการเดิมพันกีฬาและคาสิโนสดทุกวันที่ไม่ควรพลาด. ถ้าคุณกำลังมองหาประสบการณ์การเดิมพันที่น่าตื่นเต้นและเพลิดเพลิน ทางเลือกที่ดีที่สุดคือ fun88.

  18. Architectural design
    Architectural design on June 18, 2024 at 3:54 pm

    You’re so interesting! I do not suppose I’ve read through a
    single thing like that before. So good to find someone with some genuine
    thoughts on this subject. Really.. thank you for starting this up.
    This website is one thing that is required on the web, someone
    with a little originality!

  20. Interior makeover
    Interior makeover on June 22, 2024 at 3:16 am

    Link exchange is nothing else but it is just placing the other person’s blog link on your page at proper place and other person will also do same in support
    of you.

  21. Доброе утро картинки
    Доброе утро картинки on June 22, 2024 at 8:31 am

    Картинки с добрым утром https://utra-dobrogo.ru/ –
    это несложный, но очень эффективный способ поднять
    настроение себе и близким с самого утра.
    Красочные и положительные изображения с пожеланиями хорошего дня
    помогают начать день с улыбки и позитивных мыслей.
    Они могут содержать красивые пейзажи, забавные картинки, мотивирующие цитаты или милые животные, которые придают утру
    больше радости. Такие картинки
    без труда можно отправить друзьям и близким через мобильные
    приложения или соцсети, делая их день лучше.
    Начав утро с приятного пожелания, весь день может быть более
    радостным и продуктивным.

  22. Interior architecture
    Interior architecture on June 23, 2024 at 7:11 am

    Good response in return of this issue with genuine arguments and telling
    all on the topic of that.

  23. Property renovation
    Property renovation on June 23, 2024 at 3:45 pm

    Excellent blog you have here.. It’s hard to
    find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I seriously appreciate individuals
    like you! Take care!!

  24. BOKEP
    BOKEP on June 23, 2024 at 11:25 pm

    This design is steller! You most certainly know how to keep a reader
    amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Wonderful job.
    I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.
    Too cool!

  25. dewi188
    dewi188 on June 25, 2024 at 1:34 am

    My brother suggested I might like this blog.
    He was entirely right. This post truly made my day. You can not imagine
    just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

  26. Home styling
    Home styling on June 25, 2024 at 5:33 am

    You actually make it seem really easy along with your presentation however I to find this matter
    to be actually something that I think I’d by no means
    understand. It seems too complicated and very wide for me.
    I’m taking a look ahead for your subsequent publish, I’ll
    attempt to get the cling of it!

  27. Anthonycrync
    Anthonycrync on June 25, 2024 at 10:30 am

    Robert Lewandowski https://robertlewandowski.prostoprosport-ar.com is a Polish footballer, forward for the Spanish club Barcelona and captain of the Polish national team. Considered one of the best strikers in the world. Knight of the Commander’s Cross of the Order of the Renaissance of Poland.

  29. Felix Meyer
    Felix Meyer on June 28, 2024 at 8:45 am

    This was a very good post. Check out my web page Webemail24 for additional views concerning about Website Traffic.

  30. Seoranko
    Seoranko on June 28, 2024 at 4:38 pm

    Impressive posts! My blog Seoranko about Accidents also has a lot of exclusive content I created myself, I am sure you won’t leave empty-handed if you drop by my page.

  31. DonaldTup
    DonaldTup on June 29, 2024 at 12:33 pm

    mexico drug stores pharmacies
    http://cmqpharma.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
    mexican rx online

  32. StephenPoorm
    StephenPoorm on June 29, 2024 at 7:02 pm

    medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican online pharmacy – mexican mail order pharmacies

  33. ArticleHome
    ArticleHome on July 7, 2024 at 4:33 pm

    I know a lot of folks whom I think would really enjoy your content that covers in depth. I just hope you wouldn’t mind if I share your blog to our community. Thanks, and feel free to surf my website ArticleHome for content about Sports.

  34. Autoprofi
    Autoprofi on July 9, 2024 at 10:55 pm

    This is top-notch! I wonder how much effort and time you have spent to come up with these informative posts. Should you be interested in generating more ideas about Used Car Purchase, take a look at my website Autoprofi

  35. Articlecity
    Articlecity on July 10, 2024 at 4:01 pm

    I like how well-written and informative your content is. You have actually given us, your readers, brilliant information and not just filled up your blog with flowery texts like many blogs today do. If you visit my website Articlecity about Infertility Treatments, I’m sure you can also find something for yourself.

  36. HenryNof
    HenryNof on July 11, 2024 at 3:45 am

    mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexico pharmacy – mexican pharmacy

  37. MichaelmaM
    MichaelmaM on July 11, 2024 at 8:12 am

    mexico drug stores pharmacies
    https://cmqpharma.online/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
    buying from online mexican pharmacy

  38. Articleworld
    Articleworld on July 11, 2024 at 4:50 pm

    Having read your blog, you obviously know what you are talking about. I’m sure visiting my page Articleworld about Blogging will be worth your time!

  40. Article Sphere
    Article Sphere on July 13, 2024 at 1:52 pm

    Having read your posts. I believed you have given your readers valuable information. Feel free to visit my website Article Sphere and I hope you get additional insights about Website Design as I did upon stumbling across your site.

  41. tivimatepremium
    tivimatepremium on July 18, 2024 at 12:34 pm

    I loved as much as youll receive carried out right here The sketch is attractive your authored material stylish nonetheless you command get bought an nervousness over that you wish be delivering the following unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this hike

  44. CharlesSpons
    CharlesSpons on July 20, 2024 at 8:08 am

    legitimate canadian pharmacy canadapharmacyonline legit prescription drugs canada buy online

  47. Daviderect
    Daviderect on July 20, 2024 at 12:14 pm

    recommended canadian pharmacies: buying drugs from canada – onlinecanadianpharmacy

  48. Daviderect
    Daviderect on July 20, 2024 at 5:33 pm

    buy drugs from canada: canadian drugs pharmacy – canadianpharmacyworld com

  50. Michaelgof
    Michaelgof on July 20, 2024 at 6:03 pm

    medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexico pharmacy – mexico pharmacy

  53. Michaelgof
    Michaelgof on July 21, 2024 at 2:56 am

    mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  54. CharlesSpons
    CharlesSpons on July 21, 2024 at 3:35 am

    best online canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy oxycodone prescription drugs canada buy online

  55. Daviderect
    Daviderect on July 21, 2024 at 4:13 am

    world pharmacy india: best india pharmacy – buy prescription drugs from india

  62. JamesNah
    JamesNah on July 22, 2024 at 2:37 am

    buy ciprofloxacin over the counter: cipro for sale – where to buy cipro online

  64. pxhs
    pxhs on July 22, 2024 at 12:38 pm

    Its like you read my mind You appear to know a lot about this like you wrote the book in it or something I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a little bit but instead of that this is fantastic blog An excellent read I will certainly be back

  67. JamesNah
    JamesNah on July 23, 2024 at 3:50 am

    order cheap clomid no prescription: cost of clomid prices – clomid buy

  74. JamesNah
    JamesNah on July 24, 2024 at 5:58 pm

    paxlovid for sale: п»їpaxlovid – paxlovid covid

  80. Arnoldhix
    Arnoldhix on July 29, 2024 at 8:34 pm

    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexico pharmacy mexican mail order pharmacies

  88. Nelsonbap
    Nelsonbap on July 30, 2024 at 5:07 pm

    buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexican pharmaceuticals online – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  89. frizonline
    frizonline on July 30, 2024 at 7:06 pm

    I do believe all the ideas youve presented for your post They are really convincing and will certainly work Nonetheless the posts are too short for novices May just you please lengthen them a little from subsequent time Thanks for the post

  91. Waynetab
    Waynetab on July 30, 2024 at 7:38 pm

    pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexican drugstore online – best online pharmacies in mexico

  94. Waynetab
    Waynetab on July 31, 2024 at 3:44 am

    mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  96. Nelsonbap
    Nelsonbap on July 31, 2024 at 9:33 am

    medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexican rx online – mexican drugstore online

  97. DominicFox
    DominicFox on July 31, 2024 at 11:30 am

    buying from online mexican pharmacy: mexico drug stores pharmacies – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  104. Film Video Museum
    Film Video Museum on July 31, 2024 at 10:47 pm

    What i do not realize is in fact how you are no longer actually much more wellfavored than you might be right now Youre very intelligent You recognize thus considerably in relation to this topic made me in my view believe it from numerous numerous angles Its like men and women are not fascinated until it is one thing to do with Lady gaga Your own stuffs excellent All the time handle it up

  110. DominicFox
    DominicFox on August 1, 2024 at 10:52 am

    medication from mexico pharmacy: medicine in mexico pharmacies – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  112. Arnoldhix
    Arnoldhix on August 1, 2024 at 11:51 am

    pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexico pharmacy mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  121. DominicFox
    DominicFox on August 2, 2024 at 10:15 am

    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: medication from mexico pharmacy – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  130. Arnoldhix
    Arnoldhix on August 3, 2024 at 2:28 am

    п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexican rx online medicine in mexico pharmacies

  132. mediaticas
    mediaticas on August 3, 2024 at 7:43 am

    Your blog is a true hidden gem on the internet. Your thoughtful analysis and engaging writing style set you apart from the crowd. Keep up the excellent work!

  137. DominicFox
    DominicFox on August 3, 2024 at 3:57 pm

    reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexico drug stores pharmacies – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  139. Arnoldhix
    Arnoldhix on August 3, 2024 at 5:12 pm

    buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexico drug stores pharmacies п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  143. Robertnof
    Robertnof on August 4, 2024 at 11:06 am

    Misoprostol 200 mg buy online order cytotec online buy cytotec over the counter

  148. Matthewham
    Matthewham on August 4, 2024 at 6:32 pm

    cost of propecia online: cost of propecia prices – buy generic propecia

  153. Matthewham
    Matthewham on August 5, 2024 at 9:39 am

    cost of propecia: propecia pills – cost generic propecia tablets

  154. Matthewham
    Matthewham on August 5, 2024 at 4:50 pm

    aromatase inhibitor tamoxifen: tamoxifen effectiveness – nolvadex gynecomastia

  155. Matthewham
    Matthewham on August 6, 2024 at 12:04 am

    order prednisone online canada: prednisone oral – prednisone 20 tablet

  158. Matthewham
    Matthewham on August 6, 2024 at 2:28 pm

    buying propecia without a prescription: buy cheap propecia prices – get cheap propecia pill

  160. Matthewham
    Matthewham on August 6, 2024 at 9:34 pm

    generic propecia tablets: cost generic propecia pill – cost cheap propecia without a prescription

  161. best iptv smarter
    best iptv smarter on August 7, 2024 at 7:57 am

    Wonderful web site Lots of useful info here Im sending it to a few friends ans additionally sharing in delicious And obviously thanks to your effort

  162. resultado do jogo do bicho da bahia
    resultado do jogo do bicho da bahia on August 7, 2024 at 1:51 pm

    Eu amei o quanto você será realizado aqui O esboço é atraente, seu material de autoria elegante, mas você fica impaciente por desejar entregar o seguinte mal, inquestionavelmente, volte mais cedo, já que exatamente o mesmo quase muitas vezes dentro caso você proteja esta caminhada

  163. Tomasarcaf
    Tomasarcaf on August 7, 2024 at 3:47 pm

    migliori farmacie online 2024: Avanafil compresse – farmacia online piГ№ conveniente

  165. Tomasarcaf
    Tomasarcaf on August 7, 2024 at 11:42 pm

    farmacia online: avanafil in farmacia – comprare farmaci online con ricetta

  166. Tomasarcaf
    Tomasarcaf on August 8, 2024 at 7:27 am

    farmacie online affidabili: kamagra oral jelly – Farmacie online sicure

  167. Randynip
    Randynip on August 8, 2024 at 10:50 am

    viagra naturale in farmacia senza ricetta: viagra senza ricetta – cerco viagra a buon prezzo

  169. Tomasarcaf
    Tomasarcaf on August 8, 2024 at 3:37 pm

    farmaci senza ricetta elenco: avanafil generico – farmacia online

  170. Randynip
    Randynip on August 8, 2024 at 6:21 pm

    Farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: farmacia online migliore – farmacia online senza ricetta

  171. Tomasarcaf
    Tomasarcaf on August 8, 2024 at 11:52 pm

    farmacie online affidabili: Avanafil 50 mg – farmacia online piГ№ conveniente

  173. Randynip
    Randynip on August 9, 2024 at 8:59 am

    le migliori pillole per l’erezione: viagra senza prescrizione – viagra ordine telefonico

  174. Tomasarcaf
    Tomasarcaf on August 9, 2024 at 11:57 am

    farmacia online: Avanafil 50 mg – farmacie online affidabili

  176. Georgebrace
    Georgebrace on August 9, 2024 at 8:50 pm

    discount cialis online: Buy Tadalafil 20mg – how to use cialis 20mg

  177. Georgebrace
    Georgebrace on August 10, 2024 at 5:11 am

    viagra for sale: Cheap Viagra 100mg – how does viagra work

  187. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 11, 2024 at 6:07 pm

    best online ed meds: ed pills online – cheapest ed medication

  190. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 12, 2024 at 2:01 am

    reputable indian pharmacies: Best Indian pharmacy – online shopping pharmacy india

  192. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 12, 2024 at 6:39 pm

    mexican mail order pharmacies: Medicines Mexico – mexican rx online

  194. soba kalorifer sistemleri fiyatlar
    soba kalorifer sistemleri fiyatlar on August 12, 2024 at 10:43 pm

    Your articles never fail to captivate me. Each one is a testament to your expertise and dedication to your craft. Thank you for sharing your wisdom with the world.

  195. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 13, 2024 at 2:08 am

    erectile dysfunction pills for sale: Cheapest online ED treatment – erectile dysfunction pills online

  197. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 13, 2024 at 9:28 am

    buying from online mexican pharmacy: Medicines Mexico – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  198. thedeadlines
    thedeadlines on August 13, 2024 at 5:28 pm

    Its like you read my mind You appear to know so much about this like you wrote the book in it or something I think that you can do with a few pics to drive the message home a little bit but instead of that this is excellent blog A fantastic read Ill certainly be back

  199. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 13, 2024 at 5:39 pm

    mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: Best pharmacy in Mexico – mexican mail order pharmacies

  202. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 14, 2024 at 9:24 am

    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican pharmacy – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  204. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 14, 2024 at 5:07 pm

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: Best online Mexican pharmacy – reputable mexican pharmacies online

  209. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 15, 2024 at 4:04 pm

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: Certified Mexican pharmacy – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  211. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 15, 2024 at 11:09 pm

    buying prescription drugs in mexico: Best pharmacy in Mexico – best online pharmacies in mexico

  212. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 16, 2024 at 5:48 am

    purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexican pharmacy – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  213. DouglasNew
    DouglasNew on August 16, 2024 at 12:24 pm

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexico pharmacy win – best online pharmacies in mexico

  215. StanleyEmame
    StanleyEmame on August 19, 2024 at 3:07 am

    lasix generic name buy furosemide lasix dosage

  217. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 19, 2024 at 6:38 am

    buy cytotec online fast delivery http://tamoxifen.bid/# alternatives to tamoxifen
    buy lasix online

  219. StanleyEmame
    StanleyEmame on August 19, 2024 at 11:20 am

    Abortion pills online cheapest cytotec cytotec abortion pill

  220. Jameshat
    Jameshat on August 19, 2024 at 3:45 pm

    lasix 100 mg tablet: furosemide online – lasix 40 mg

  222. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 19, 2024 at 4:56 pm

    cytotec abortion pill https://lipitor.guru/# lipitor brand name cost
    lasix dosage

  223. StanleyEmame
    StanleyEmame on August 20, 2024 at 2:33 am

    tamoxifen warning buy tamoxifen online what happens when you stop taking tamoxifen

  225. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 20, 2024 at 3:01 pm

    Misoprostol 200 mg buy online http://lipitor.guru/# lipitor rx
    lasix furosemide 40 mg

  227. Jameshat
    Jameshat on August 20, 2024 at 10:09 pm

    lasix furosemide 40 mg: furosemide online – lasix pills

  228. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 21, 2024 at 5:40 am

    Misoprostol 200 mg buy online http://tamoxifen.bid/# arimidex vs tamoxifen bodybuilding
    lasix furosemide 40 mg

  229. StanleyEmame
    StanleyEmame on August 21, 2024 at 6:46 am

    buy generic lipitor canada best price for lipitor cost of lipitor in australia

  233. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 21, 2024 at 8:08 pm

    Misoprostol 200 mg buy online https://furosemide.win/# lasix furosemide
    furosemide 40mg

  236. Jameshat
    Jameshat on August 22, 2024 at 7:29 am

    lipitor brand name: buy lipitor 20mg – lipitor generic brand name

  237. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 22, 2024 at 10:35 am

    buy cytotec online fast delivery http://furosemide.win/# furosemide 100mg
    generic lasix

  238. Jameshat
    Jameshat on August 22, 2024 at 9:30 pm

    lasix generic name: lasix for sale – furosemida

  239. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 23, 2024 at 12:00 am

    order cytotec online http://cytotec.pro/# Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
    lasix 20 mg

  241. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 23, 2024 at 12:56 pm

    Misoprostol 200 mg buy online https://lipitor.guru/# lipitor generic drug
    lasix uses

  243. Jameshat
    Jameshat on August 23, 2024 at 6:01 pm

    lasix 100mg: buy furosemide – furosemide 100 mg

  244. Jameshat
    Jameshat on August 24, 2024 at 12:53 am

    tamoxifen endometriosis: buy tamoxifen online – tamoxifen

  245. DanielMut
    DanielMut on August 24, 2024 at 2:03 am

    Cytotec 200mcg price http://cytotec.pro/# buy cytotec pills
    lasix furosemide

  250. Hermandip
    Hermandip on August 25, 2024 at 9:38 pm

    buying prescription drugs in mexico online: mexican pharmaceuticals online – mexican mail order pharmacies

  251. Anthonyalili
    Anthonyalili on August 26, 2024 at 12:27 am

    п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india indian pharmacy online reputable indian pharmacies

  254. Petergat
    Petergat on August 26, 2024 at 6:13 am

    canadian pharmacy tampa: canada cloud pharmacy – canadian family pharmacy

  255. Anthonyalili
    Anthonyalili on August 26, 2024 at 10:57 am

    northwest pharmacy canada canadianpharmacyworld canadian pharmacy 24h com safe

  260. kalorifer soba
    kalorifer soba on August 26, 2024 at 7:49 pm

    Nice blog here Also your site loads up fast What host are you using Can I get your affiliate link to your host I wish my web site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  261. Petergat
    Petergat on August 27, 2024 at 1:28 am

    top 10 pharmacies in india: india pharmacy mail order – top 10 pharmacies in india

  263. Hermandip
    Hermandip on August 27, 2024 at 6:32 am

    buy prescription drugs from india: top online pharmacy india – india online pharmacy

  265. Ремонт смартфонов
    Ремонт смартфонов on August 27, 2024 at 8:29 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту сотовых телефонов, смартфонов и мобильных устройств.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт телефонов москва
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  266. Ремонт телефонов
    Ремонт телефонов on August 27, 2024 at 9:28 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту сотовых телефонов, смартфонов и мобильных устройств.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт телефонов поблизости
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  268. JesusEncop
    JesusEncop on August 27, 2024 at 5:23 pm

    deneme bonusu: bonus veren siteler – deneme bonusu veren siteler

  272. Ремонт телефонов
    Ремонт телефонов on August 28, 2024 at 6:51 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту сотовых телефонов, смартфонов и мобильных устройств.
    Мы предлагаем: срочный ремонт сотовых телефонов
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  273. JesusEncop
    JesusEncop on August 28, 2024 at 7:26 am

    sweet bonanza hilesi: sweet bonanza kazanc – sweet bonanza hilesi

  274. ремонт ноутбуков в москве
    ремонт ноутбуков в москве on August 31, 2024 at 5:02 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту ноутбуков и компьютеров.дронов.
    Мы предлагаем:сервисный центр по ремонту ноутбуков в москве
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  279. Hishseads
    Hishseads on September 2, 2024 at 2:06 pm

    priligy buy 5, n 15, followed by inhibition of folic acid metabolism required for the synthesis of bacterial DNA and RNA 28

  283. Darrelcleri
    Darrelcleri on September 3, 2024 at 12:08 pm

    slot oyunlar? siteleri: slot kumar siteleri – deneme veren slot siteleri

  286. ремонт ipad в москве
    ремонт ipad в москве on September 4, 2024 at 12:29 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту планетов в том числе Apple iPad.
    Мы предлагаем: сервис по ремонту ipad
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  287. Darrelcleri
    Darrelcleri on September 4, 2024 at 3:11 am

    en guvenilir slot siteleri: slot oyun siteleri – slot oyun siteleri

  289. ремонт ipad в москве
    ремонт ipad в москве on September 4, 2024 at 8:07 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту радиоуправляемых устройства – квадрокоптеры, дроны, беспилостники в том числе Apple iPad.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт квадрокоптеров цены
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  293. ремонт айпадов в москве
    ремонт айпадов в москве on September 4, 2024 at 11:18 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту планетов в том числе Apple iPad.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт айпада
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  296. ремонт квадрокоптеров москве
    ремонт квадрокоптеров москве on September 4, 2024 at 1:15 pm

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту радиоуправляемых устройства – квадрокоптеры, дроны, беспилостники в том числе Apple iPad.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт квадрокоптеров в москве на карте
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  297. Scotttwene
    Scotttwene on September 4, 2024 at 1:59 pm

    пин ап зеркало: пинап казино – пин ап казино вход

  299. LeslieAffes
    LeslieAffes on September 4, 2024 at 6:36 pm

    пин ап вход pin up пин ап зеркало

  301. Scottdense
    Scottdense on September 4, 2024 at 7:35 pm

    вавада зеркало: vavada online casino – vavada

  309. Scotttwene
    Scotttwene on September 5, 2024 at 2:07 pm

    пин ап: pin up casino – pin up casino

  311. Scottdense
    Scottdense on September 6, 2024 at 2:21 am

    пин ап зеркало: пинап казино – пин ап вход

  313. Ремонт iPhone в Москве
    Ремонт iPhone в Москве on September 6, 2024 at 4:33 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту Apple iPhone в Москве.
    Мы предлагаем: срочный ремонт iphone в москве
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  315. Ремонт ИБП в Москве
    Ремонт ИБП в Москве on September 6, 2024 at 4:48 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту источников бесперебойного питания.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт ибп стоимость
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  319. Ремонт бесперебойников
    Ремонт бесперебойников on September 6, 2024 at 10:04 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту источников бесперебойного питания.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт ибп
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  320. Scottdense
    Scottdense on September 6, 2024 at 11:56 am

    1xbet официальный сайт мобильная версия: 1xbet – 1xbet официальный сайт

  321. Scottdense
    Scottdense on September 6, 2024 at 9:26 pm

    пин ап казино вход: пинап казино – пин ап казино

  328. Ремонт варочных панелей
    Ремонт варочных панелей on September 7, 2024 at 4:52 pm

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту варочных панелей и индукционных плит.
    Мы предлагаем: варочная панель ремонт
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  329. ремонт бытовой техники в екатеринбурге
    ремонт бытовой техники в екатеринбурге on September 7, 2024 at 4:56 pm

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем:ремонт крупногабаритной техники в екатеринбурге
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  331. ремонт техники в екб
    ремонт техники в екб on September 8, 2024 at 11:28 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем:сервис центры бытовой техники екатеринбург
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  339. DrstoCauro
    DrstoCauro on September 9, 2024 at 3:30 pm

    target finasteride pharmacy: Dostinex – Cialis Soft Tabs

  346. DrstoCauro
    DrstoCauro on September 10, 2024 at 10:29 pm

    online pharmacy reviews reddit: ed medication – viagra australia pharmacy

  348. Ремонт фотоаппаратов
    Ремонт фотоаппаратов on September 11, 2024 at 3:24 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту фото техники от зеркальных до цифровых фотоаппаратов.
    Мы предлагаем: мастер по ремонту фотоаппаратов
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  349. itsnewsed
    itsnewsed on September 11, 2024 at 10:33 am

    Hello Neat post Theres an issue together with your site in internet explorer would check this IE still is the marketplace chief and a large element of other folks will leave out your magnificent writing due to this problem

  350. Ремонт фотоаппаратов
    Ремонт фотоаппаратов on September 11, 2024 at 3:47 pm

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту фото техники от зеркальных до цифровых фотоаппаратов.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт цифровых фотоаппаратов
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  354. MauriceMat
    MauriceMat on September 11, 2024 at 11:41 pm

    india online pharmacy: indianpharmacy com – best online pharmacy india

  356. Ремонт планшетов в Москве
    Ремонт планшетов в Москве on September 12, 2024 at 4:37 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту планшетов в Москве.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт планшетов
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  359. Ремонт планшетов
    Ремонт планшетов on September 12, 2024 at 10:01 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту планшетов в Москве.
    Мы предлагаем: сервис по ремонту планшетов
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  361. ремонт техники в новосибирске
    ремонт техники в новосибирске on September 12, 2024 at 12:44 pm

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем:сервис центры бытовой техники новосибирск
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  362. MauriceMat
    MauriceMat on September 12, 2024 at 1:07 pm

    lansoprazole pharmacy: proscar uk pharmacy – online pharmacy discount code 2018

  363. Josephsog
    Josephsog on September 12, 2024 at 6:16 pm

    pharmacy website india india online pharmacy india pharmacy mail order

  364. сервис центры в новосибирске
    сервис центры в новосибирске on September 12, 2024 at 6:49 pm

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем:сервисные центры по ремонту техники в новосибирске
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  368. MauriceMat
    MauriceMat on September 13, 2024 at 3:36 am

    india online pharmacy: india pharmacy – reputable indian pharmacies

  379. Josephsog
    Josephsog on September 14, 2024 at 3:28 am

    rx pharmacy richland wa online india pharmacy zocor pharmacy protocol

  381. MauriceMat
    MauriceMat on September 14, 2024 at 6:51 am

    buy prescription drugs from india: indian pharmacy – indian pharmacy paypal

  383. ремонт техники в москве
    ремонт техники в москве on September 14, 2024 at 8:02 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем: сервисные центры в москве
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  386. ibomma
    ibomma on September 14, 2024 at 10:57 am

    Excellent blog here Also your website loads up very fast What web host are you using Can I get your affiliate link to your host I wish my web site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  388. Josephsog
    Josephsog on September 14, 2024 at 2:23 pm

    Online medicine home delivery Online medicine order cheapest online pharmacy india

  397. Ремонт стиральных машин в Москве
    Ремонт стиральных машин в Москве on September 15, 2024 at 11:08 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту стиральных машин с выездом на дом по Москве.
    Мы предлагаем: ремонт стиральной машины москва
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  399. сервис центры в казани
    сервис центры в казани on September 15, 2024 at 11:20 am

    Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем: сервисные центры по ремонту техники в казани
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *